LogoPet-1.png
BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 9 Best Vibrating Dog Collars That Are Humane

Training a dog is difficult, particularly when it's difficult to gain the dog's attention.

However, many of the unavoidable training techniques are also quite brutal, putting discriminating pet owners in a difficult position.

These vibrating collars are an ideal compromise, since they attract your dog's attention without causing him actual discomfort.

Therefore, they are a humanitarian answer to the enormous training issue. Unfortunately, not all of them function as well as they should.

In the evaluations of the best vibrating dog collars that are humane that follow, BestForPets (bestforpets.org) will explain which collars we believe will be fantastic complements to your dog's training regimen and which ones are just glorified necklaces.

Reviews

Best Overall: DogRook No Shock Training Collar

The DogRook No Shock has two modes to select from: sound and vibration. This allows you to begin with a purely non-physical treatment then, if required, shift to vibration.

It has seven distinct vibration levels, so you won’t immediately overwhelm your dog with a strong rumble. This makes it an excellent option for fearful dogs, and owners never have to worry about applying more vibration than required.

The collar is adjustable and suits dogs weighing between 10 and 110 pounds. Additionally, the strap is water-resistant, so you need not worry if your dog decides to take a brief swim in the pool while wearing it.

The major drawback of the DogRook is that it is not appropriate for teaching numerous dogs simultaneously. The issue is that it is triggered by barking regardless of its source, thus one dog’s barking would set off the collars of both dogs, confusing both.

The problem can be resolved by staggered training, and it isn’t an issue for everyone, so we didn’t believe it was enough to knock the DogRook off the top place.

Pros

  • Utilizing sound or vibration
  • 7 vibration settings
  • Good for shy dogs
  • Fits dogs weighing 10 to 110 pounds
  • Strap resistant to water

Cons

  • Not appropriate for concurrently training many dogs

No Shock Bark Collar by NPS – Best Value

The NPS No Shock takes care of one component of training by automatically adjusting its vibration levels based on the duration of your dog’s barking. This eliminates the need for you to take any action and also helps manage bothersome barking while you are away from home.

It combines vibrations with beeps, and both persist as long as your dog continues to bark. This is a double-edged sword, since it means that your dog cannot just ignore the vibrations until they cease, but it also means that she may eventually learn to ignore them.

The good news is that it is calibrated to ignore false triggers, so you don’t have to worry about harmless triggers, such as your dog moving her head or another dog barking, accidently setting it off.

Given its inexpensive cost, it is quite unexpected that this gadget is so complex. Because of this, it is our selection for the most humane vibrating dog collar for the money. Our only fear is that it may lose efficacy with time, which is why it’s not at the top of the list.

Pros

  • Adjusts automatically the vibration levels
  • Vibrates and beeps concurrently
  • Ignores false triggers
  • Budget-friendly pricing
  • Ideal for usage while the owner is away.

Cons

  • May lose efficiency over time

SportDOG E-Collar — A Premium Option

The Sport DOG Brand 425 E-Collar puts the power in your hands — literally, owing to the accompanying remote control — unlike other collars that buzz automatically.

The remote has a range of 500 yards and many modes, such as vibration, sound, and static stimulation.

You may disagree with the usage of static stimulation, but you are not required to use it, and it is available if you need it. In addition, it has 21 levels of strength, so if you decide to give it a try, you may begin with a mild setting.

This machine can teach up to three dogs concurrently (although that would require purchasing two additional collars). Additionally, the remote’s battery is rechargeable and often recharges within two hours.

Beyond concerns about humane treatment, the price of the SportDOG Brand 425 E-Collar is the major sticking point. It is not inexpensive, and you may hesitate to connect such an expensive piece of equipment to a hairy machine that intends to consume it.

However, if you can afford it, it is certainly worth every cent. We simply do not know if it is superior to the two alternatives mentioned above it.

Pros

  • Includes remote with a range of 500 yards
  • Produces sound, vibration, and stimulation via static charge
  • Static stimulation offers 21 levels of intensity.
  • Can teach three dogs at once
  • Regenerative battery

Cons

  • Some individuals could find static stimulation cruel.
  • Highly costly

Mini GoodBoy No Shock Collar

As its name implies, the GoodBoy Mini is a very little gadget, and your pet will likely not even notice it until it begins to buzz. Given that it provides nine degrees of vibration, the intensity of the wake-up call is up to you.

This item’s diminutive size is due to its design for little dogs. Puppies weighing as low as five pounds may wear it comfortably, and they won’t feel like they’re dragging a millstone around their necks. On the other hand, larger dogs may not even detect it, even if you want them to.

This device also has a remote with a range of 1,000 feet. This makes it perfect for both backyard training and inside practice.

The GoodBoy Mini does not, however, without problems. Aside from the fact that it is possibly insufficient for bigger breeds, the remote’s buttons are absolutely smooth. This makes it hard to determine which button is which without looking, which is distracting while training.

This may be a nice starting point if you have a toy-breed dog. Otherwise, we would suggest attempting one of the three alternatives listed above.

Pros

  • Excellent dogs as tiny as 5 pounds
  • 9 vibration levels
  • Remote has a range of 1,000 feet
  • Compatible for outdoor usage

Cons

  • Larger dogs may not detect it.
  • The buttons on the remote cannot be touched.

TBI Pro V7 Dog Harness

We have no clue what is inside the TBI Pro V7, yet it seems to be very advanced. In addition to having a database of over 5,000 dog sounds, which helps reduce false activations, this gadget is no fool.

Additionally, it includes two vibration motors, allowing it to be more powerful than some of the other models on this list. The vibrations are initiated by a dog’s bark, but you may set the collar to “normal” mode if you never want your dog to experience the strongest vibrations.

However, crying and wailing will not activate it, so do not expect it to remove all undesirable vocalizations. Additionally, the strap does not keep it in place very well, and it is continually shifting around the dog’s neck. This may be problematic since there are locations where the dog is far less likely to perceive vibrations.

Overall, the TBI Pro V7 is a clever gadget that falls short of its full potential. In addition, it makes your pet appear like a futuristic war dog, which is a bummer.

Pros

  • Large database of dog vocalizations to reduce false positives.
  • Dual vibration motors
  • Susceptible to intense vibration

Cons

  • Will not quit weeping or complaining
  • Slides around a lot

POP VIEW Dog Bark Collar

The POP VIEW lets you to adjust its sensitivity, so you can set it to vibrate at the slightest sound or wait until your dog is barking loudly for it to activate. It features a trigger so sensitive that simply breathing on it might cause it to vibrate.

This sensitivity makes it susceptible to false alerts, particularly in families with many dogs. However, you may also set it off by speaking to or caressing your dog excessively, which would undermine the objective.

It’s odd that a computer with such sensitivity would also be so unreliable. It doesn’t always go off when it’s supposed to; one moment it vibrates because you murmured to your dog while patting her, and the next it remains silent while she growls at the mailman.

It is not the most durable product, which is maybe unsurprising considering its modest price. Still, it would be preferable if it lasted more than a few months before having to be replaced.

You may discover that the POP VIEW collar is more bother than it’s worth, despite its reasonable price.

Pros

  • Can adjust sensitivity
  • Budget-friendly model

Cons

  • Irritatingly sensitive at maximum setting
  • Prone to false alarms
  • Also prone to misfires
  • Not extremely durable

Remote Dog Training Collar WOLFWILL

The WOLFWILL Remote’s basic black ABS shell doesn’t catch much notice, so you won’t have to answer as many questions about this collar as you would about others on our list.

It is also entirely waterproof, making it a wonderful option for individuals who like swimming with their dogs. The remote is simple and quick to operate, and it also features a convenient belt clip. Beyond that, though, there is not much to appreciate about this collar.

It contains 16 levels of vibration, however there is little variation between them, so that number is rather deceptive. Also, even at its maximum setting, it’s unlikely to penetrate thick fur, so if you have a Husky, you’ll need to purchase a model with a stronger motor or shave her.

The remote must also be charged after every use, which is inconvenient, and it often stops holding a charge after a few months. The WOLFWILL Remote has some intriguing characteristics, but they are insufficient to compensate for its other faults.

Pros

  • Absolute waterproofness
  • User-friendly remote

Cons

  • Little difference between vibration levels
  • Will not penetrate thick coatings
  • The remote requires regular recharge
  • The lifespan of batteries is a few months.

No Shock, Paws Furlosophy Dog Collar

The Paws Furlosophy is priced in the center of the pack, but there are other alternatives that cost half as much that exceed it.

The largest issue is not necessarily the collar’s functionality, but rather the battery’s intermittent ability to keep a charge. It’s difficult to determine whether it’s juiced up until you’re out in the field, despite the fact that it’s of little use if it lacks any.

It is rather cumbersome and may be a burden for dogs under 50 pounds. In addition to being difficult to set up, the instructions are almost worthless.

It has a respectable range of 650 yards and is fully waterproof, making it perfect for usage in any environment. Beyond that, though, we found nothing to recommend about the Paws Furlosophy.

Pros

  • 650-yard range
  • Water-resistant structure

Cons

  • Expensive for what is received
  • Occasionally, the battery keeps a charge.
  • Possible too hefty for dogs less than 50 pounds
  • Instructions have no value

BIG DEAL No Shock-Free Dog Training Collar

The BIG DEAL is offered at a cheap price, but there is no question that you get what you pay for. The collar is composed of cheap plastic, and if your dog is a rough-and-tumble kind, it will not last long. It may be incapable of causing significant vibration due to its cheap build, enabling it to be easily disregarded.

Additionally, there is a tiny delay between the remote and the collar, which may not seem like a significant problem, but may completely derail training. Your dog will not identify the vibration with the undesirable action, and she will likely get confused and frustrated.

The buttons aren’t very intuitive, and the directions aren’t very helpful, so anticipate a lot of trial-and-error before you figure out how to use it. However, the large size of the buttons should lessen the risk of mistakenly pressing the incorrect one.

Other affordable collars on this list demonstrate that you don’t need to spend a money on a quality training tool, therefore it’s difficult to suggest the BIG DEAL at this time.

Pros

  • The buttons are plenty and well placed.

Cons

  • Made of low-cost plastic
  • Not able to generate significant vibrations
  • Interval between the remote and collar
  • Buttons lack intuitiveness.
  • Instructions are ineffective.

Buyer's Guide

Any kind of training aid will obviously attract the suspicion of dog owners, and some have even been known to spark confrontations amongst dog lovers.

In the following article, we’ll cover all you need to know about vibrating collars so you can determine whether purchasing one is a good idea.

How Do They Function?

When your dog engages in undesirable behavior, often barking, the collar vibrates around her neck. Sometimes the vibration is automatically activated, and sometimes the owner must manually activate it.

The main premise is that a quick and unexpected buzzing around her neck will attract her attention and prompt her to cease the harmful activity. Then, you may refocus her energies toward something more beneficial or praise her for discontinuing the undesirable behavior.

Are They Inherently Human?

Ultimately, it depends on how you define “humane.”

A vibrating collar should never cause discomfort. However, it may still be employed as a kind of punishment, and many people consider all forms of punishment to be brutal. These individuals are of the opinion that only positive reinforcement should be utilized.

There are compelling arguments on both sides. You must decide for yourself whether you’re willing to employ punishment in your dog’s training, but at least you can rest easy knowing you didn’t harm your pet.

Do They Actually Function?

As with any other training strategy, it is impossible to answer this issue. In the end, so much relies on how they are used and if the trainer is consistent.

It is a truth that some dogs react positively to them, while others do not seem to notice them. It is also hard to predict how a dog would react beforehand, but dogs with thick coats are less likely to notice vibrations unless they are really intense.

You must also exercise caution while using them, lest you confuse your puppy and add additional complexity to your training routine.

However, they seem to be very helpful for teaching deaf dogs, since they enable you to gain their attention without initially making eye contact.

How Are They Designed to Be Used?

If you have a collar that vibrates automatically, the issue should fix itself (if the collar functions as intended).

If you have one with a remote, though, you should utilize it to attract attention. In other words, you want to stop the undesirable behavior so you can educate your dog how to behave instead.

If your dog is barking at the mailman, for instance, you may buzz her collar. Hopefully, this will halt her in her tracks, and she will likely be bewildered. You may then intervene, get her attention, and redirect her energy with a different order.

You should not just use it as a buzzer that you activate if your dog does anything you dislike. This will not cure the issue and will only educate the dog to disregard the vibrations in the near future.

FAQs

1. How does a vibrating collar for dogs work?

Vibrating collars use a signal to control undesirable behaviors, such as excessive barking, in dogs. The dog immediately becomes distracted upon detecting the vibration via the rubber or metal prongs fastened to his neck.

2. What size vibrating collar does my dog require?

Before estimating and purchasing the gadget, it is essential to measure the dog’s neck size. After measuring the size, read the product description to ensure a proper fit.

3. How long do these collars’ batteries last?

The lifetime of batteries might differ across brands. On average, it may last around two weeks.

4. Is there a maximum age at which dogs may wear vibrating collars?

According to several experts, pups less than 8-10 weeks old should wear vibrating collars. Consult your veterinarian before to utilizing any equipment on your dog.

5. Should I remove my collar at night?

There is no need to force the dog to wear a collar at night if he is resting calmly, particularly if he is secured inside the home with you.

6. How loud is the noise of the vibration?

The collar is completely silent. The vibration serves solely as a signal to divert your dog’s behavior. When the dog gets the vibration signal, he immediately stops barking.

7. Are vibration collars painful for dogs?

These collars do not harm the pets. In fact, many dog owners prefer this style over shock collars.

Conclusion

The DogRook No Shock is BestForPets‘ (bestforpets.org) favorite vibrating collar because to its seven distinct vibration levels, which let you to pick between a gentle prod and a blaring alarm.

The NPS No Shock makes training simple despite its inexpensive price, since it automatically changes its vibration settings to fit your dog’s activity levels. Attaching it is all that is required; it will even disregard false alarms.

These evaluations of the best vibrating dog collars that are humane should have convinced you that a vibrating collar may be both effective and compassionate. Purchasing any kind of correctional device might cause dog owners to feel remorse.

In the end, a mild nudge is significantly better than letting your dog to disregard his manners, given that some undesirable habits might result in his death.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Comment

0.0
Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles