BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 11 Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs

It can be difficult to control a dog's aggression if the dog is very stubborn.

Particularly susceptible to this problem are herding breeds such as the Border Collie and the German Shepherd.

If you are an unskilled owner or cannot afford professional training, a necklace may be your only effective option.

However, it can be difficult to choose a reliable brand because there are so many to choose from.

To help you make an informed decision, we've reviewed many of the best training collars for resistance dogs.

We'll take a look at the pros and cons of each option, and we've included a brief buyer's guide to give you a feel for what to look out for as you continue your search.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) hopes you can find the best training collars for stubborn dogs for your pet.

Finding the Right Collar: A Buyer's Guide

A Collar with Steel Prongs or One that Shocks You Electrically

Steel prongs and s can hurt your pet, causing it to act differently around you and the collar. That’s why it’s best to only resort to these tools when absolutely required if you want to train your dog to behave appropriately.

Many of these devices have adjustable shock levels, so you can start with one that isn’t too unpleasant for your pet and work your way up from there if necessary.

In spite of your distance, your dog will still be able to sense your presence thanks to these reliable technologies. Large dogs, who may not be affected by the electric shock from many brands because they cannot provide the volts sufficient to modify their behavior, can be successfully disciplined with the steel prong.

A pronged collar is used to attach the leash, letting the dog know who is in charge, and allowing the owner to choose the level of pressure applied.

Use caution while implementing behavioral modification with these collars, and consult your veterinarian for advice.

Distinction of the Collar

Many different manufacturers boast about the extensive range of their electric collars. Controlling your dog from afar is a lovely idea in theory, but it’s hardly practical to administer electric shocks to an animal you can’t see.

Avoid manufacturers that advertise a range of more than half a mile, as even a modest improvement in that metric might result in a price hike.

Anti-Weathering Collar

While researching manufacturers to evaluate, we were surprised to see how few of them offered waterproofing. You probably already knew this if you’ve been a dog owner for any length of time, but many canine varieties like going for a swim.

They spend a lot of time outdoors in the damp, so any non-waterproof paint won’t stay long. We made an effort to review only waterproof products and will highlight any manufacturers that fall short.


If you have a dog that is particularly difficult to train, we recommend that you consider our highest-rated training collar.

With a range of up to 500 feet, the SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X Remote Training Dog Collar allows you to shock your dog just enough to change its behavior.

Author Image

Dr. Barry Buttler

Dr. Barry Buttler, DVM, MS, DACVIM, is an experienced veterinarian who specializes in the care of small animals, specifically dogs. Dr. Barry K. Buttler is a member of the American Veterinary Medical Association and holds multiple certifications in small animal emergency medicine and geriatric pet health.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Barry Buttler


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles