LogoPet-1.png
BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 10 Best Peanut Butter For Dogs In 2024

Dogs have different tastes for treats and meals, but peanut butter seems to be a favorite among them all. You can use peanut butter as a training aid, a reward, or to add excitement to frozen dog toys.

While small amounts of food-grade peanut butter are safe for your canine, it may contain high amounts of sugar, palm oil, salt, and preservatives.

Pet owners should be particularly cautious about peanut butter brands that use xylitol as a sweetener, as it is harmful to dogs and can cause seizures, liver damage, and even death.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) recommends that pet owners choose peanut butter brands (such as the ones we reviewed) that do not include xylitol in their best peanut butter for dogs.

icon Vet Approved
icon Reviewed & Fact - Checked by

Deborah R. Fletcher (DVM)

Veterinarian

The information provided is current and up-to-date, in line with the latest research conducted in the field of veterinary medicine.

Read more icon

Our Top Picks Compared

Image Product View on Amazon
1 Hill's Soft Dog Treats Hill's Soft Dog Treats View on Amazon
2 KONG - Easy Treat - Dog Treat Paste KONG - Easy Treat - Dog Treat Paste View on Amazon
3 BUDDY BUDDER Bark Bistro Company BUDDY BUDDER Bark Bistro Company View on Amazon
4 365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter With Salt 365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter With Salt View on Amazon
5 Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter View on Amazon
6 Zuke's Mini Naturals Dog Training Treats Zuke's Mini Naturals Dog Training Treats View on Amazon
7 Hill's Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care Original Flavor Wet Dog Food Hill's Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care Original Flavor Wet Dog Food View on Amazon
8 Hyper Pet Dog Peanut Butter Hyper Pet Dog Peanut Butter View on Amazon
9 Pooch Creamery Ice Cream Mix Peanut Butter Dog Treats Pooch Creamery Ice Cream Mix Peanut Butter Dog Treats View on Amazon
10 NATURE'S LOGIC Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat NATURE'S LOGIC Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat View on Amazon

Reviews

1. Hill’s Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treat 

Hill's Soft Dog Treats, Soft Savories with Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Snacks

View on Amazon

  • The Hill’s Science Diet brand
  • Soft Savory Dog Biscuits
  • Eight ounces

We recommend Hill's Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treats as the best-value peanut butter delight for canines, based on extensive research.

These delights contain no artificial flavors or preservatives and are made with natural ingredients. All ages of canines enjoy their distinctive combination of sweet and savory flavors.

Peanut butter, potatoes, cane molasses, poultry fat, peanuts, peas, bananas, citric acid, lactic acid, porcine gelatin, glycerin, and wheat flour are included as ingredients.

Hill’s Science Diet offers a money-back guarantee on these soft and chewable delights, which are suitable for any life stage.

Please note, however, that if your dog is allergic to gluten or wheat, you should choose a different brand.

The Hill’s Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treats are a natural and tasty peanut butter delight that your furry companion will appreciate. They are reasonably priced and accompanied by a guarantee of satisfaction.

Pros

Affordable

Organic ingredients

Favorable for dogs that enjoy soft chews

Cons

Includes both wheat flour and peas


2. Peanut butter recipe for KONG Stuff-N-Easy Treats

KONG - Easy Treat - Dog Treat Paste

View on Amazon

  • Product Type: Spread Dispenser
  • Weight: Eight ounces

Kong toys are among the most popular dog products, providing an excellent chewing experience for dogs of all sizes.

However, the Kong Stuff'N Easy Treat Peanut Butter Recipe , a popular spread dispenser designed to be used with Kong toys, may not be the healthiest option for dogs.

Unlike human-grade peanut butter available in grocery stores, Kong’s formula includes artificial flavors, milk protein concentrate, caramel color, preservatives, and glucono-delta-lactone.

Moreover, the product does not contain peanuts or peanut butter, and the spread may escape from the toy too quickly unless frozen for 30-45 minutes.

We recommend using natural, high-quality peanut butter spreads with Kong toys to provide optimal nutrition and flavor for dogs.

Our top choices are free from artificial flavors, preservatives, and other additives, ensuring a healthy and delicious treat for your furry friend.

In summary, Kong toys are an excellent option for dogs who love to chew, but the Kong Stuff’N Easy Treat Peanut Butter Recipe may not be the healthiest or most natural option for dogs.

By using natural peanut butter spreads with Kong toys, you can provide your dog with a healthy and enjoyable chewing experience.

Pros

Built-in nozzle distributes peanut butter mixture

Cons

Artificial flavors, preservatives, unneeded spices

Liquid consistency

Costly for 8 ounces


3. Buddy Budder Raw Peanut Butter by Bark Bistro Company

BUDDY BUDDER Bark Bistro Company

View on Amazon

  • Brand: Buddy Budder
  • Type: Peanut Butter Spread
  • Size: 1.0 pound

Bark Bistro Company's Buddy Budder Ruff Ruff Peanut Butter Lickable Dog Treats received the award for the best overall peanut butter for dogs.

This peanut butter spread is made from just wildflower honey and unsalted dry-roasted peanuts. It does not contain added salt, sugar, high-fructose corn syrup, preservatives, or stabilizers.

Typically, peanut butter brands sold in grocery stores use stabilizers to maintain a creamy texture at room temperature. All-natural varieties, such as Bark Bistro’s, must be stirred and chilled to retain a smooth consistency.

We selected Bark Bistro as our top choice due to the recipe’s simplicity and excellent feedback from dog owners. The product contains only two ingredients, yet it provides antioxidants, protein, manganese, healthy fats, and vitamin E.

You can use it as a treat, to conceal medication, or present it directly to your dog. However, the only downside to the product is its price. It is not the most expensive option, but it is quite expensive for a pound of peanut butter.

Buddy Budder’s peanut butter is an all-natural, healthy treat for dogs that is suitable for human consumption. It contains only two simple ingredients: peanuts and honey.

It does not contain harmful ingredients, such as high fructose corn syrup, stabilizers, xylitol, artificial sugar, or salts.

Refrigerating the peanut butter will cause it to thicken, making it easier to stuff inside dog enrichment toys or use as a pill pocket.

It is suitable for puppies, adult dogs, and dogs of all sizes, but pet owners should exercise discretion when introducing a new treat to their dogs.

Buddy Budder’s peanut butter has multiple uses, such as enjoying it from a spoon, using it as a lick mat, baking treats, making frozen treats with silicone molds, and using it as a pill pocket to hide the taste of medicine.

The product’s ingredients are high quality, regionally sourced, and manufactured in the USA. Buddy Budder takes pride in manufacturing its treats to ensure the delivery of a quality product.

In summary, Buddy Budder’s peanut butter is an all-natural, healthy treat for dogs, made from high-quality ingredients and suitable for various uses, offering pet parents a range of options for their furry friends. It’s a perfect option for those who prioritize their dog’s health and wellbeing.

Pros

Not excessive in salt, sugar, or stabilizers

Constructed using dry-roasted peanuts and wildflower honey

Dogs adore the flavor

Cons

Expensive


4. 365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter With Salt

365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter With Salt

View on Amazon

365 by Whole Foods Market's Creamy Peanut Butter with Salt  is a premium product that guarantees the highest quality and flavor for your pet. Made with peanuts sourced from the United States, this peanut butter is a healthy and natural delicacy for your companion.

This peanut butter provides a nutritious option for your pet, as it contains no added sugar and is carefully crafted.

Please note that it is not a low-calorie product, and it is important to consider the calorie, total fat, and sugar content before incorporating it into your pet’s diet.

Similar to the joyful experience of dancing down the aisles at Whole Foods Market, 365 by Whole Foods Market offers a wide variety of affordable products made with premium ingredients. Our commitment to quality extends to all of our pet products.

As an Amazon brand, we prioritize your satisfaction and your pet’s well-being. Their professional and knowledgeable customer service team is available six days a week, Monday through Saturday, to address any questions or concerns you may have.

Pros

Made with 100% U.S.A. peanuts

No added sugar

Premium quality and taste

Wholesome and natural treat for pets

Offers a wide range of choices with premium ingredients

Affordable prices

Cons

Not a low-calorie food

Nutritional values should be considered


5. Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter

View on Amazon

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter  is a proud American product made exclusively with peanuts grown in the United States. We are dedicated to providing peanut butter that meets the highest standards of flavor and nutrition.

This peanut butter is Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Vegan-Friendly, and Kosher, catering to a variety of dietary restrictions and preferences. It take pride in using only natural ingredients and refrain from adding any preservatives or carbohydrates.

As a family-owned and operated business since 1925, it have upheld a tradition of delivering authentic and genuine peanut butter. Unlike peanut butter “spreads,” Teddie is a true Natural peanut butter that contains nothing but the goodness of peanuts.

We understand the importance of offering a nutritious option for your pet. Although this peanut butter is not specifically marketed for pets, it can be a safe and delicious treat for them.

As always, please consult with your veterinarian to ensure it aligns with your pet’s dietary needs.

Pros

Made in the USA using only USA-grown peanuts

Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Vegan Friendly, and Kosher

No preservatives or sugars added

Family-owned and operated since 1925

A true Natural peanut butter, not a spread

Cons

Not specifically marketed for pets (consult with a veterinarian before feeding it to your pet)


6. Mini Naturals Training Dog Treats from Zuke’s

Zuke’s Mini Naturals Adult Dog Treats

View on Amazon

  • Product Type: Treats
  • Size: 16 fluid ounces

Early training is crucial for helping your puppy develop into a happy, well-behaved pet, as puppies can be unpredictable and unruly.

To reward your puppy during training, we recommend Zuke's Mini Naturals Training Dog Treats , an all-natural peanut butter treat that is low in calories and high in moisture.

These treats are primarily made of peanut butter, rice, oats, tapioca starch, and cherries, making them a healthy and tasty choice for your furry friend. They are a pleasant incentive for dogs in training, helping to shape their behavior in a positive way.

Despite their health benefits, it is worth noting that Zuke’s treats do contain some ingredients that could be harmful to your pet’s health, such as barley extract, potato protein, and phosphoric acid.

Pet owners should use discretion when introducing a new treat to their dogs and monitor their pets’ behavior and health closely.

For a wholesome and tender natural dog treat that is ideal for all your training adventures, try Zuke’s Mini Naturals Dog Training Treats in the chicken recipe. These soft dog treats are less than 3 calories per treat, making them a guilt-free reward for your dog.

With real chicken as the primary ingredient, these soft and chewy dog treats are suitable for small, medium, and large dogs. They also feature natural ingredients such as whole food berries and come in a resealable pouch for added convenience.

In conclusion, Zuke’s Mini Naturals Training Dog Treats and Mini Naturals Dog Training Treats in the chicken recipe are both excellent options for pet owners looking to reward their pups during training.

While they both contain some ingredients that may be harmful to your pet’s health, they are a healthy and delicious choice for your furry friend when used in moderation.

Pros

Small snacks are perfect for training

Low in calories and rich in moisture

All-natural ingredients

Cons

Extraneous ingredients


7. Hill’s Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care

Hill's Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care

View on Amazon

Hill's Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care Canned Dog Food  is specially formulated to support your companion’s digestive health. This high-quality food, developed by Hill’s nutritionists and veterinarians, is clinically proven to calm and soothe the digestive tract.

The highly digestible, low-fat formulation of this dog food aids digestion and promotes nutrient absorption. It is designed to be gentle on the stomach, making it ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs or those recovering from gastrointestinal issues.

The inclusion of prebiotic fiber in this food promotes the growth of beneficial microflora in your dog’s digestive tract, enhancing digestive health. By nourishing the intestinal flora, this product helps maintain a healthy balance in your pet’s digestive system.

Hill’s Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care Canned Dog Food is made with high-quality ingredients and is carefully formulated to provide essential nutrients while being gentle on the digestive system.

It is an excellent option for dogs with digestive conditions that require a low-fat diet.

As a trusted brand in pet nutrition for nearly three decades, Hill’s has been a leader in developing specialized diets. This prescription diet demonstrates their commitment to quality and expertise.

If you have any questions or concerns about this product, Hill’s customer service team in the United States is available six days a week to assist you.

Please consult your veterinarian to determine if Hill’s Prescription Diet i/d Low Fat Digestive Care Canned Dog Food meets your dog’s specific dietary requirements.

Pros

Specially formulated to support digestive health

Clinically proven to calm and soothe the digestive tract

Highly digestible, low-fat formula

Contains prebiotic fiber for beneficial gut health

Made with premium ingredients

Cons

May not be suitable for dogs with specific dietary restrictions or allergies

Requires a veterinarian’s prescription


8. Peanut Butter Pet Hyper IQ Treat Spread

Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter

View on Amazon

  • Product Type: Spread
  • Size: 17 fluid ounces

Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter is an all-natural spread that is specifically formulated for dogs.

This product is made in the USA and contains only roasted peanuts and honey, without any added sweeteners, preservatives, artificial colors, or other additives. It is a rich source of protein, healthy fats, and essential vitamins such as E, B, and niacin.

This peanut butter for dogs can be used as a treat, training aid, or as a supplement to your pet’s regular diet. It can be spread on slow feeding trays, lick mats, Kong toys, or refrigerated to create pill pockets.

However, some consumers have reported issues with the spread’s consistency upon delivery, as they may not be familiar with natural peanut butter. The product may separate, but can be easily mixed to achieve a smooth and creamy texture.

Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter is an excellent alternative to other peanut butter brands that may contain xylitol, a harmful ingredient for dogs.

Furthermore, it does not contain high fructose corn syrup, stabilizers, artificial sugars, or salt. The product comes in a variety of flavors such as bacon, pumpkin, banana, and natural peanut butter, allowing pet owners to mix and match flavors to create delicious treats for their furry friends.

In summary, Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter is a high-quality, all-natural product that is a safe and healthy option for dogs of all life stages.

It provides essential nutrients and can be used in various ways as a treat, training aid, or supplement to your pet’s diet.

Pros

Contains peanuts and honey

Can be refrigerated for pill pockets

Offers nutritious fats and protein

Cons

Tough to stir

Expensive


9. Canine Peanut Butter Ice Cream Mix Treats from Pooch Creamery

Pooch Creamery Ice Cream Mix Peanut Butter Dog Treats

View on Amazon

  • Product Type: Peanut Butter Powder Mix
  • Weight: 5.25 ounces

Pooch Creamery Peanut Butter Flavor Ice Cream Mix Dog Treat is an excellent option for pet owners seeking a special treat to celebrate their furry friend’s birthday or other special events.

Unlike other peanut butter items, this product is a powder that you hydrate with water and freeze for eight hours.

The product is made from natural components, including peanuts, lactose-free milk, cane sugar, gelatin, and salt, carefully selected to provide optimal nutrition and flavor for dogs.

The Pooch Creamery treat is grain-free, making it a suitable option for dogs with sensitivities.

One downside of the product is its prolonged processing time. After freezing for eight hours, it must defrost for 10 to 15 minutes at room temperature. Additionally, the product is affordable, although 5.25 ounces may not last very long.

In summary, Pooch Creamery Peanut Butter Flavor Ice Cream Mix Dog Treat is an excellent option for pet owners prioritizing natural ingredients and quality nutrition for their furry friends.

Made with just five premium ingredients and sourced in the USA, the product is lactose-free, grain-free, and easy to store. While the processing time may be longer than other treats, it is ideal for special occasions or whenever you want to give your dog a special reward.

Pros

Perfect for canine birthdays

Contains five all-natural components

Cons

Preparation time exceeds 8 hours

After freezing, it must be defrosted

Small serving for the cost


10. Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat by Nature’s Logic

NATURE'S LOGIC Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat

View on Amazon

  • Product Type: Spread
  • Size: 12 fluid ounces

Nature's Logic Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat is a high-quality, all-natural product designed to provide essential nutrients to dogs.

The product is made from three simple ingredients: peanuts, coconut oil, and chia seeds, carefully chosen to deliver a range of health benefits to dogs.

Chia seeds are an excellent source of omega-3 fatty acids, essential for optimal health and wellness. Coconut oil is known for its digestive benefits, improving digestion and nutrient absorption in dogs.

Peanuts provide essential protein for maintaining healthy muscles, bones, and tissues.

Unlike many competitors, Nature’s Logic does not use stabilizers to replicate the consistency of human-grade peanut butter.

However, some consumers have reported that the spread is too runny, making it challenging to use as a toy filler or to create pill pockets. The product can be poured into a bowl or on a lick tray, but the consistency may not be suitable for all uses.

In summary, Nature’s Logic Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat is an excellent option for pet owners seeking an all-natural, high-quality product that provides essential nutrients to dogs.

Made from simple natural ingredients, it is free from stabilizers and other additives. While the consistency may not be suitable for all uses, it is a great choice for pet owners prioritizing natural ingredients and quality nutrition for their furry friends.

Pros

Constructed using chia seeds, peanut butter, and coconut oil

Contains neither preservatives nor synthetic flavors

Cons

Poor formulation

After chilling, the substance is too soft for pill pockets

Buying Guide: Selecting the Finest Peanut Butter for Dogs

Since peanut butter is likely one of your dog’s favored indulgences, it makes sense to find a nutritious and appetizing brand to wow your pet.

Peanut butter intended for humans that does not contain excessive amounts of sugar, sodium, or preservatives is a suitable substitute for peanut butter intended for canines.

However, ensure that it does not contain the sweetener xylitol to avoid a negative reaction. If you have not yet decided on a peanut butter product for your dog, consider the following factors to help you make a decision.

1. Peanut Butter Cost and Quantity for Dogs

Some of the peanut butter spreads we evaluated are considerably more expensive than human-grade peanut butter, but the vast majority are healthful and do not contain excessive sugar, sodium, or preservatives.

The premium brands with fewer ingredients may appear to be more expensive, but the container size must be considered when determining a product’s value.

For instance, some consumers found the price of our top decision to be too costly. However, Bark Bistro’s spread arrives in a 1-pound container that lasts significantly longer than the 8-ounce canister of our previous pick.

2. Dog Peanut Butter Type

Spreads of peanut butter are noisier than individual delights, but more versatile. Some brands, such as Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter, allow you to refrigerate or chill the combination to construct your own pill pockets or chew toy.

Convenient and less expensive than powdered mixtures or premium spreads, peanut butter-based delights are more accessible and affordable than their powdered or premium counterparts.

3. Dog Peanut Butter Consistency and Texture

Several dog owners complained that the peanut butter constituents were separated when they received their dispatches, but this is typical for products containing only two or three components.

When purchasing high-quality peanut butter from a supermarket, the same separation occurs. Every time you use products containing only honey and ground peanuts, you must thoroughly combine them.

Some products, such as Nature’s Logic Canine Peanut Butter Spread Dog Treat, do not thicken sufficiently even when chilled, despite the fact that they contain peanut butter.

4. Dog Peanut Butter Ingredient List

You can expect to pay a bit more for peanut butter for canines, but before paying a premium price, you should examine the product’s constituents.

Expensive brands loaded with additional sugar and preservatives are not healthier than human-grade products, but there are a number of brands, such as our first and fifth choices, that use only peanuts and honey in their formulations.

FAQs

1. Is regular peanut butter safe for dogs as a treat?

Yes, it is acceptable for canines to consume peanut butter as a treat. However, avoid peanut butter containing Xylitol, as it is the only peanut butter constituent that can be toxic to canines.

2. What makes dog peanut butter different?

The true distinction between dog peanut butter and many human brands of peanut butter is not what is added, but what is not.

While many human peanut butter recipes include additional sodium, sugar, oils, or flavorings, dog peanut butter typically consists of only peanuts.

3. Is peanut butter good for all dogs?

No, not all peanut butter brands are safe for dogs. Some peanut butter contains xylitol, which is toxic to dogs even in small amounts and could be fatal.

Xylitol is an artificial sweetener that is often used in sugar-free products.

4. What peanut butter is safe to eat?

Look for peanut butter that contains only peanuts and possibly salt. Avoid peanut butter that contains added sugar or vegetable oils that have been hydrogenated.

5. How much peanut butter is good for dogs?

If provided as a treat, a small quantity will be just as exciting to your dog as a large amount. It is reasonable to limit peanut butter to a half teaspoon twice daily for small dogs as a starting point.

Maximum daily dosage for a medium or large dog is 1 teaspoon, twice per day.

6. Is peanut butter good for a dog’s stomach?

In small amounts, yes. As a general rule, dogs should only consume a tablespoon or less of peanut butter. Consuming more than that can sometimes cause mild stomach upset, so it’s important to feed them in moderation.

Conclusion

Several companies are producing peanut butter products that are safe for dogs to meet the growing demand, and our reviews indicate which ones are the best.

Buddy Budder Raw Peanut Butter by Bark Bistro Company are our top overall choice after examining a number of exceptional alternatives. The product uses only wildflower honey and peanuts, and dogs seem to love the natural taste.

The winner of the category for the best value is the Hill's Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treat . The treats at Hill’s are tender, tasty, and made with natural ingredients. The application process is mess-free, unlike spreading.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) would like to thank our readers for visiting our website to learn about the best peanut butter for dogs. We hope you have chosen the appropriate peanut butter product for your furry friend.

Author Image

Dr. Barry Buttler

Dr. Barry Buttler, DVM, MS, DACVIM, is an experienced veterinarian who specializes in the care of small animals, specifically dogs. Dr. Barry K. Buttler is a member of the American Veterinary Medical Association and holds multiple certifications in small animal emergency medicine and geriatric pet health.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Barry Buttler

Comment

0.0
Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles