BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 11 Best No-Shock Training Collars

Do you have a dog who barks all day while you're away? Even though we don't want to, we sometimes have to tell our best little friends what to do when they do something wrong.

There are thankfully several alternatives that allow you to avoid startling the dog, reducing the possibility of causing them discomfort or even agony. We intend to merely train the dogs, not harm them!

We don't have to take a chance thanks to some amazing and well-thought-out products that put dogs first! From high-tech to budget-friendly, BestForPets (bestforpets.org) has a variety of fantastic solutions that will get you and your dog set up in no time!

Here are our best no-shock training collars, beginning with the most advanced.


Garmin Barklimiter Deluxe Dog Training Collar – Best Overall

 Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe, Rechargeable Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: N/A
  • Battery Life is three months
  • Type of Deterrent: Vibration and shock
  • Recommended Pet Weight or Age: All ages, with larger breeds preferred
  • Includes fright: Yes

The Garmin Barklimiter Deluxe Dog Training Collar is our top recommendation for pet owners with a large dog and a severe barking issue.

These are, so to speak, the heavy guns and are not suggested for lesser breeds. Occasionally, it is in the dog’s best interest for the correction to be successful, and some dogs have exceptionally thick skin!

This device employs a vibration, but it also has a shock and vibration option, so make sure you are aware of its current configuration. For the sake of this article, this will count as a strike against the item, although its capacity to detect intensity places it higher on the list.

The vibrations increase automatically as the dog continues to bark, which is effective. In terms of humanity, we also appreciate the design’s intuitiveness. It is designed to differentiate between barking and other vocalizations and avoids incorrect corrections pretty well.


  • Excellent battery life
  • Automatic allocation of intensity
  • Intuitive design


  • Contains a shock function as well
  • Not for tiny dogs

GroovePets Automatic Anti-Bark Humane Static Shock Waterproof Collar – Best Price

 GROOVYPETS 1100 YD Remote Dog Training Shock Collar with Auto Anti Bark

View on Amazon

  • Range: 1,100 yards
  • Battery Life is forty days
  • Deterrent Type: acoustic, vibratory, and static
  • Weight or age recommendations: All sizes, 6 months or older
  • Includes fright: Yes

The GroovyPets One Dog Set 1100 Auto Anti Bark Humane Beep Vibration Static Shock Waterproof Collar  is an excellent alternative for individuals who enjoy taking their pets outside, even into the true wilderness.

The remote’s range of 1100 yards and its battery life of more than a month make it ideal for use in the backcountry. This design appears to place a high priority on the dog’s comfort, as silicon caps avoid discomfort.

The only drawbacks of this fantastic training collar are that it is a single set and that it has a shock function. If you have two dogs and wish to use this otherwise excellent remote, you will require two sets.

This may be less than ideal, but it won’t be the end of the world for most; this is an outside collar.


  • Excellent range
  • Amazing battery life
  • Designed for comfort


  • Contains shock
  • One dog only

PetSafe Water-Resistant Rechargeable Spray Dog Bark Collar – Top Pick

 PetSafe Spray Bark Dog Collar, Automatic No Bark Device for Dogs 8 lb. and Up

View on Amazon

  • Range: N/A
  • Battery Life is forty hours
  • Types of deterrents: spray, ultrasonic, and shock
  • Recommended Pet Weight or Age: 8 pounds or more, 6 months or older
  • Includes fright: Yes

The PetSafe Water Resistant Rechargeable Spray Dog Bark Collar  is a water-resistant variant of the vibration collar featured above by the same manufacturer.

This item is even more cheap for pet owners on a tight budget. The only drawback is that it also includes a minor shock option that is described as feeling like tickling, but you must be careful not to use it.

A citronella spray cartridge is also available, which is a painful but humane punishment. This collar is a fantastic choice for those of us who don’t have much money for a training collar but need one immediately because to its mild and stain-resistant spray.


  • A setup where an ultrasonic deterrent is employed is ideal
  • Citronella is a mild and efficient insect repellent
  • Excellent value choice


  • Disposable spray cartridges are a consumable
  • Includes option for mild shock

PetSpy M919 Premium 12 Mile Training Collar – Most Effective for Multiple Dogs

 PetSpy M919 Dog Training Shock Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: 880 yards
  • 72 hours of battery life
  • Types of deterrents: vibration, sound, and shock
  • Weight or age requirements: Over 10 lbs
  • Includes fright: Yes

PetSpy M919 Premium 12 Mile Training Collars  are ideal for owners who wish to take their dogs out on the farm or into the wilderness. They have a range of 880 yards and can operate for 72 hours on a single charge.

These collars have received several favorable reviews, but they are large, hefty, and bright orange. In addition, they contain a shock function, which detracts from their score; nonetheless, few purchasers offer unfavorable feedback.

Even though they resemble prison shackles, they appear to have a high customer satisfaction rating and are a viable solution for training dogs in the vast outdoors.


  • Great variety
  • Acceptable battery life
  • Highly rated in reviews


  • Option for shock included
  • Big, colorful, and voluminous

PetSafe Remote Vibration Dog Training Collar

 PetSafe Vibration Remote Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: 100 yards
  • 14 days for battery life
  • Deterrent Type: Vibration
  • Weight or age recommendations: All sizes, 6 months or older
  • Includes surprise: No

PetSafe is a manufacturer of a comprehensive selection of no-shock training collars, and hence has two entries on our list. First, the PetSafe Vibration Remote Dog Training Collar  is a bark collar that utilizes solely vibration.

This remote training collar has a range of 100 yards, which is adequate for a park or a path but insufficient for hunting, tracking, or agriculture. In conclusion, this is a very sturdy collar with an excellent value-to-cost ratio.

You may select from sixteen vibration settings, and it is safe for dogs of all sizes. This collar is supposedly effective for training deaf or hard-of-hearing dogs, which is something we like.

The only drawbacks we discovered were a few claims of low battery life, but for the majority of customers, this collar delivers!


  • Only vibration, perfect for deaf or hard of hearing dogs
  • Versatile
  • Excellent choice for value, effectiveness, and humane deterrent


  • A few issues regarding battery life

No Electric Shock Remote Dog Training Collar by PatPet

 PATPET-Dog-Training- Shock & No Shock Option Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: 600 yards
  • 10 days for the remote and 512 days for the collar
  • Deterrent Tone, vibration, and light
  • Recommended Pet Weight or Age: 30 – 110 pounds and older (at least 6 months)
  • Includes surprise: No

The PatPet No Electric Shock Remote Dog Training Collar is waterproof and affordably priced, and it features three non-shock deterrents. The collar’s design is extremely attractive, since it is fairly subtle and not as big as others we’ve seen.

Its specifications are also extremely amazing. With a 600-yard range, it is possible to traverse reasonable terrain. Additionally, the collar has a battery life of 512 days, which is acceptable.

It’s excellent to have a variety of humane alternatives when calibrating the collar to your dog’s specific needs, making this a perfect interim solution for sensitive canines.

It allows you to choose between intensities, and the remote will alert you if the stimulation becomes too intense for your dog, which is a convenient function.


  • The design completely prioritizes the dog’s comfort
  • Great variety
  • Acceptable battery life for weekend excursions
  • Best option for dogs with less tolerance


  • Limited size range—not for dogs under 30 pounds

Rechargeable PetSafe Remote Spray Dog Collar

 PetSafe Remote Spray Trainer, Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: 300 yards
  • Battery Life is forty hours
  • Types of Deterrents: Spray, vibration, and sound
  • Recommended Pet Weight or Age: 8 pounds or older, or six months or older
  • Includes surprise: No

If you prefer simpler paths with adequate visibility and don’t mind a spray collar, the PetSafe Rechargeable Remote Spray Dog Collar  is a fantastic alternative.

However, this training system features two additional no-shock modes: vibration and tone. We appreciate having alternatives! While this one may not have the range for the backwoods, 300 yards is more than plenty for the majority of people.

This is a fantastic alternative if you enjoy going to the park and perhaps hiking a little route. The main disadvantage is that the citronella cartridges must be replaced, which does increase the price slightly.

Nevertheless, if your dog responds to sound or vibration, you are off the hook. This is a fairly realistic alternative for the needs of the ordinary pet owner.


  • Great humane deterrent alternatives
  • Versatile
  • Decent range


  • Not the greatest option for powerless multiday treks
  • Cartridges are a consumable

Eyenimal Deluxe Lemon Fragrant Non-Bark Spray Collar

 Eyenimal PFABOSPR037 Deluxe Spray No Bark Collar

View on Amazon

  • Range: N/A
  • Lifespan of batteries: 3 years
  • Deterrent Type: Spray
  • Recommended Pet Weight or Age: over 6 months
  • Includes surprise: No

We enjoy that the Eyenimal Deluxe Lemon Scented No Bark Spray Collar  takes a mild approach. It works by spraying a lemon-scented mist that is perfectly safe, except that your pet dislikes the fragrance.

It is activated by vibration, so it lacks complexity in identifying whether your dog is barking or not. Although the spray is harmless, it loses its value as a teaching tool if it misfires.

We have not yet received complaints of this, and the battery life is extremely impressive. Hopefully, it won’t be in full-time usage after three years, unless you have additional pets who require correcting!

Again, a spray collar must be refilled in some way, but this one utilizes citronella refills rather than cartridges.


  • Excellent battery life
  • The spray is safe


  • Citronella is a consumable

Wagz Freedom Intelligent Pet Collar

 Wagz® Freedom Smart Dog Collar™, Shock-Free Wireless Pet Containment and Wellness System with Wagz Phone App

View on Amazon

  • Connects to a smartphone with an “unlimited range.”
  • Battery Lifespan: None
  • Vibration and ultrasonic stimulation are the types of deterrents used
  • Recommended Weight or Age for a Pet: Any
  • Includes surprise: No

The Wagz Freedom Smart Dog Collar  training system is our top selection due to a single outstanding characteristic. Have you ever been away from home and want to monitor your dog’s activities?

We certainly have. This method enables you to build up an invisible fence and monitor your pet’s movements! It employs GPS technology and transmits the data to your smartphone. That is very awesome!

We particularly enjoy how it links to your smartphone; however, a subscription to the app is required. However, if you’re ready to download the app, this is a terrific, more cheap smart tool than an invisible fence.

Fantastically, it employs solely vibrations and ultrasonic stimulations as opposed to any type of shock. A fantastic training aid for dog owners!


  • GPS monitors your dog’s movements.
  • Modern humane deterrents
  • Not shocking


  • Requires a monthly fee-based subscription

How to Choose the Best No-Shock Training Collar for Your Dog

Choosing the appropriate equipment is a vital aspect of putting you and your dog up for success. Regarding the purchase of a training collar, it’s all about trust, dependability, and meeting the specific demands of your dog.

Always go deeply into the research and reviews, and evaluate the quality of the product.

Appropriate size is an additional crucial factor. This may seem simple to some, but the majority of these mechanical collars employ little prongs to detect barking.

Choosing the incorrect size may lead it to malfunction when it should function or to repair itself when it shouldn’t. Both are unhealthy for you and your dog. Ensure you get the correct size for your dog.


We appreciate the thoughtfulness and effort that goes into their creations. How can you efficiently punish a dog without being too harsh? This is a major obstacle in dog training.

These no-frills options, which range from technology to the great outdoors, help you figure out the line between love and tolerance, which can help you change the way you act.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) would like to thank our visitors for visiting our website to learn about and research the best no-shock training collars. We hope that you have selected the appropriate dog training collar.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles