BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 10 Best Litter Boxes For Picky Cats

We've all had the finicky cat for whom you can't seem to find the perfect litter box. But you can't just quit up because a litter box is an essential aspect of being a cat owner.

So, if your cat is a kitten, is getting older, or is simply particular about how his litter box is kept or even how big it is, these reviews are for you.

You might have three or four cats, and one of them doesn't enjoy sharing litter boxes, or your elderly feline companion can't quite make the leap into that high-sided litter box anymore.

Whatever your situation is, you must locate a cat litter box that works for both of you.

This is where the reviews come in handy. BestForPets (bestforpets.org) will list the best litter boxes for picky cats, provide some pros and disadvantages, and even provide a guide to assist you make the best decision.


Nature’s Miracle Designed Specifically for Cats – Best Overall

Nature’s Miracle Just for Cats, in our opinion, is the greatest overall litter box for fussy cats. It is extra-large, with lots of space for your cat to turn around or for more than one cat.

It features high sides to keep the litter within the box but not so high that your cat can’t leap in and out. In fact, the entry point has been kept low precisely for this purpose.

Another reason we like this litter box is because it has built-in odor control and non-sticking features.

With no stuck litter to pull out and no foul stink wafting through the home, this one takes the top spot on our list.

The main disadvantage of this litter box is that because it is an open pan, your cats will have no privacy, which may irritate some cats.


Best Buy: Pet Mate Basic Cat Litter Pan

The finest litter box for picky cats is ranked second on our list. The Pet Mate Basic Cat Litter Pan easily takes that slot.

If your cat is naturally clean and orderly with his litter, this simple pan is a terrific choice. It’s inexpensive, has a comfort grip rim for easy emptying, and is simple to clean.

The comfort grip assists you in stabilizing the pan so that it does not buckle and spill when emptying.

The tough plastic makes cleaning a breeze, and even the large version is reasonably priced.

The main disadvantage of this box, as with the first on our list, is the open pan, which provides no seclusion for your cat.


Kitten-Friendly Booda Dome Cleanstep Litter Box

If your kitten is still learning to use the litter box, he may be hesitant and apprehensive. He requires a litter box with an easily accessible entry point as well as the privacy to utilize the box itself.

That’s where the Booda Dome Cleanstep Litter box, ranked fourth on the list, comes in.

The entryway stairs are grooved to prevent your child from trailing litter out of the box and onto your pristine surfaces.

The box contains a nonstick spherical pan and a charcoal filter in the roof to ensure that no aromas filter down and out into your home.

The main drawbacks to this domed litter box are the need to purchase replacement charcoal filters and the fact that it is difficult to clean because it is enclosed rather than an open pan.


Top Entry Cat Litter Box Iris

If you want something more modern in your cat litter box but don’t want to pay modern designer costs, the Iris Top Entry Cat Litter Box might be your best bet.

It includes a closed lid to keep messes at bay and an entry point in the top of the box.

However, this box isn’t simply for decoration in your apartment. It’s also utilitarian, with high sidewalls and a top entry point that keeps spray out.

It’s ideal for compact locations like the bathroom or a small apartment, and it even includes a litter scoop that hangs neatly on a hook attached to the exterior of the box.

While this is a terrific idea for smaller cats, jumping up and climbing into the box may not be appropriate for adult cats.


Cat Litter Box Omega Paw Roll’N Clean

The Omega Paw Roll’N Clean Cat Litter Box is a self-cleaning litter box as well, however it is less expensive than some others on the market.

Many self-cleaning litter boxes either do not work as promised or startle the cats who use them due to the loud noises made by the self-cleaning mechanism.

This litter box is self-cleaning, but it is not automated, therefore it is less expensive and quieter.

Instead of automatic cleaning, this box has a grill in the bottom that separates the litter from the waste, making cleaning easier.

This one has a cover to prevent litter from being tossed out of the box and to provide your feline with privacy when needed.

The only drawback we discovered with this cat litter box was that it requires only clumping litter to function effectively.

Choosing the Best Litter Box for Picky Cats: A Buyer's Guide

Now that you’ve seen a few of the best litter boxes for fussy cats, it’s time to move on to our shopping guide.

We’ll assist you in determining the appropriate litter box for your cat’s needs and will tell you what to look for. But first, you should be able to visualize the ideal bathroom.

That restroom will be comfortable for a human to move about in, clean, well-lit, and devoid of foul odors. Consider your cat’s litter box. Is this the ideal bathroom for him?

If you can say the following about your cat’s litter box, it’s time to replace it. If your cat is extremely particular, you may need to spend a bit extra time locating the perfect litter box.

We’ll go through a few topics you should think about below.

Think about the Cats

One of the first things to consider when selecting a litter box is the number of cats you have.

For example, if you only have one cat who uses the litter box, it will be easier to pick one that will keep him happy and meet his needs.

However, if you have numerous cats, it may be more difficult.

It is recommended that you keep one litter box that is well-kept, well-lit, and exceptionally clean for each cat you own, plus one additional.

If you have numerous cats, this is especially crucial because cats may be territorial and choosy, which means that if one of your cats doesn’t enjoy sharing, he may find another area to use the potty, which is the last thing you want to deal with.

Different cats, different tastes

Cats, like humans, have diverse preferences when it comes to restroom facilities.

One cat may prefer a covered litter box because he prefers privacy, whilst another cat may not care. Some cats dislike being confined and prefer an open pan.

If you have more than one picky cat, you may need to test many different cat litter boxes from our list to locate the appropriate one.

Whatever litter box you choose, cleaning it out every day and changing the litter on a regular basis can assist to keep the box clean, control any unpleasant odors, and guarantee your cat is willing to use it.

Consider your cat’s age, size, and health

When looking for the best litter box for your cat, consider his or her size, age, and overall health in mind. For example, the litter box you select for a kitten may not be suitable for an elderly cat.

Furthermore, some senior cats or those with specific medical issues may be unable to jump into a litter box with a top access point or high edges.

Keep these considerations in mind when you conduct your research for the best outcomes.

Litter Selection Is Beneficial

The days of having no option in the matter of cat litter are long gone. You can now pick between clumping and non-clumping litter.

The decision, though, is entirely up to your cat. Some cats enjoy clumping, while others do not. Sifter boxes and self-cleaning boxes are excellent and less difficult to clean.

However, if your cat dislikes clumping litter or is afraid of the noise made by the self-cleaning mechanism, you’ve squandered your money on that type of litter box.

Take your time, observe the type of litter your cat prefers, and then conduct research to identify the best litter box for you and your cat on the list.

Keep in mind that no matter how much you enjoy a particular litter box, if your cat doesn’t like or approve of it, that litter box won’t be of any use to you.

Last Thoughts

This brings us to the end of our top ten reviews of the best litter boxes for picky cats. Nature’s Miracle Just for Cats is our top overall recommendation because to its low entrance sides. 

Because of its low cost and basic design, the Pet Mate Basic Cat Litter Pan is the greatest litter box for the money. Sometimes all you need to please your picky cat is a simple box.

Finally, BestForPets (bestforpets.org) recommends the Smarty Par Leo’s Loo Covered Automatic Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box because of its simple design and digital possibilities.

These reviews should assist you in selecting the ideal litter box for your fussy cat, so that both of you can be pleased in the days ahead.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles