BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 14 Best Kinds Of Cat Litter For Picky Cats

Before you welcome a cat into your home, make sure you have all of the necessary items for your cat. What about cat food? Got it! Dishes for food and water?

Check! A extremely gorgeous cat bed that also happens to complement your own bed? Check again! What about litter for cats?

You purchased a large bag on sale that should last at least a month. Everything is ready for your new kitten. However, as the weeks pass, you realize that the cat is not using its litter pan.

You're perplexed. You placed the litter pan in a private location. You checked for cleanliness on a daily basis. You also made sure the litter pan was easy for the cat to get into. What exactly is going on?

Your cat may dislike the cat litter. This issue must be rectified as soon as possible! The post from BestForPets (bestforpets.org) discusses the best kinds of cat litter for picky cats on the market.


Dr. Elsey’s Cat Attracts Clumping Clay Litter – Overall winner

  • Litter Composition: Clay
  • Scented: Yes
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: No

Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Attract Litter is the suggested litter for cats who are picky about their cat litter. This litter has a natural herbal smell that attracts cats.

Along with the aroma, the texture and size of the litter particles make it appealing to even the most picky cats. Because Dr. Elsey’s recipe is hard clumping, it can be used in a sifting or mechanical litter box.

This formulation is not hypoallergenic and may be less dusty. Overall, the herbal aroma of this litter is its selling point, and it might make training your cat a lot less distressing.


  • Herbal smell that works
  • A pleasant trash particle texture
  • The formula is clumpy.


  • Expensive
  • A little dusty


Best Premium BoxiePro Air Probiotic Clumping Cat Litter

  • Litter Composition: Barley and grass
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

Premium cat litter may appear to be an unnecessary expense for your cat, but it is sometimes the best option for you and your pet.

As a result, BoxiePro Air Lightweight Deep Clean Probiotic Unscented Clumping Cat Litter is our recommendation. BoxiePro Air Lightweight is comprised of barley and grass, making it lighter than clay-based cat litters.

This litter’s plant-based composition appeals to cats because it creates a more natural environment in which they can discharge themselves.

However, because this litter is so light, your cat may track it outside of the pan. A mat or cloth placed beneath the litter pail will assist decrease tracking in your home.


  • Litter with probiotics
  • Eco-friendly
  • Cats find it appealing to use


  • Litter is tracked.


Fresh Step Unscented Clumping Cat Litter – Most Economical

  • Litter Composition: Clay
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: No

Fresh Step is a well-known brand of cat litter, thus this is the best affordable cat litter for your picky kitten.

Fresh Step’s Advanced Simply Unscented Clumping Cat Litter is suitable for cats because it is unscented and contains activated charcoal, which aids in the absorption of ammonia odors in urine.

Because strong synthetic scents used to hide odors may be too overwhelming for their sensitive sinuses, these two aspects make this litter appealing to fussy cats.

One concern with this litter is that, despite the fact that it claims to be virtually dust-free, some dust clouds were observed when pouring and scooping the litter. This litter can also be tracked by your cat’s paws.


  • There are no dyes or perfumes.
  • Activated charcoal is used.
  • Ideal for finicky kitties


  • Litter is easily tracked.
  • Not completely dust-free


Scoop of Wheat Clumping Unscented Wheat Cat Litter – The Best Eco-Friendly Litter

  • Wheat is used as a litter material.
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

Most people are increasingly conscious of their environmental impact, and your dogs are no exception. House cats require litter, but are there eco-friendly solutions available that are of high quality for finicky cats?

Our suggestion is s Natural Unscented Clumping Wheat Cat Litter Wheat Scoop Is this wheat-based kitty litter? Indeed! Wheat starch absorbs odors well, making it an environmentally friendly cat litter option.

It is both biodegradable and flushable! This litter, however, is dusty and easily tracked around the house due to its composition of wheat starch.

To reduce mess, an old towel or a mat should be placed beneath the litter pan.


  • Eco-friendly
  • Free of dye, smell, and artificial ingredients
  • Flushable and biodegradable


  • Expensive
  • Cats can track dusty surfaces.


Best Scented Litter – World’s Best Lavender Scented Corn Cat Litter

  • Litter Composition: Corn
  • Scented: Yes
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

Not all scented cat litters have a strong and strange odor. Some can be scented in a way that is pleasing to both your cat and you.

One of these cat litters is the World’s Best Lavender Scented Clumping Corn Cat Litter, which comes highly recommended.

This corn-based litter is blended with 100% natural lavender oil, making it biodegradable and flushable in most septic and sewer tanks.

The oil and fast-clumping litter composition work well together to reduce the odor of the cat’s excrement. One thing to keep in mind with this litter is that it is perfumed, which may turn off certain cats.

This litter can also be tracked outside the litter pan of the cat.


  • The lavender smells wonderful.
  • Environmentally friendly litter
  • Safe for septic and wastewater tanks, flushable


  • Some cats may dislike the fragrance.
  • Can be followed around the house


Kitten Litter – Naturally Fresh Herbal Clumping Walnut Cat Litter

  • Walnut shell as litter material
  • Scented: Yes
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

It is never too soon to spoil – and house train — your kitten. Naturally Fresh Herbal Attraction Scented Clumping Walnut Cat Litter is intended to entice kittens and senior cats to waste themselves in a litter pan.

This finely powdered walnut shell litter is low-tracking and filled with a natural herb blend that will entice even the pickiest kittens to utilize it.

When using this litter, you can also feel good about your environmental effect because it is cultivated responsibly, flushable, and made with non-GMO materials.

One disadvantage of this litter is that it does not clump as well as other types of litter.


  • Affordable
  • There is little dust.
  • Ideal for kittens


  • A lack of clumping ability


Original Wood Clumping Cat Litter by KOCAT – Best Wood Litter

  • Litter Composition: Wood Fiber
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

For discerning cat owners, a simple and natural litter is frequently the best option. If you believe your picky cat might prefer a wood-based litter, KOCAT Original Premium Wood Clumping Cat Litter is recommended.

Wood-based litter has advantages for both cats and the environment. Because the wood fiber is naturally perfumed, cats with sensitive noses will not be put off by an artificial odor that other litters may hide.

The litter is also environmentally friendly because it is biodegradable and plant-based. One issue with this litter is that the combination of wood fibers can cause some cats to sneeze, which may dissuade them from using it.


  • Plant-based and eco-friendly
  • Litter with little dust
  • Naturally fragrant


  • Cats may sneeze when using wood-based litter.
  • Litter is a combustible substance.


Recycled Paper Pellet Cat Litter – The Best Pellet Litter

  • Litter Composition: Recycled paper
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

Some cat owners have had poor results with other litters in terms of tracking and dust-free living. This is why pellet litter is becoming increasingly popular.

Our top pick for pellet litter is Fresh News Recycled Paper Original Pellet Multi-Cat Litter. The pellets are constructed of 100% recycled paper and baking soda and easily absorb fluids.

Paper pellet litters are especially appealing to cat owners since they do not adhere to cats’ paws, reducing additional clean-up.

Because these paper pellets do not clump, scents are not as easily absorbed as they would be in other types of litter. This litter would work best in a covered litter box with a charcoal filter.


  • Outside pan is not tracked.
  • Dustless litter
  • Effectively absorb liquid


  • Odors are not absorbed by litter.


Odor-Lock Crystal Cat Litter So Fresh – Best Crystal Litte

  • Litter Composition: Silica gel crystals
  • Scented: No
  • Clumping: No
  • Biodegradable: No

If your cat leaves really fragrant gifts, a crystal-based litter may be the best solution. Petco’s So Phresh Odor-Lock Crystal Cat Litter is the recommended brand among the crystal litter options on the market.

The non-toxic silica gel crystals absorb your cat’s pee for about a month before the litter needs to be changed. If you have numerous cats, though, the litter box may need to be replaced more frequently.

Some cat owners were concerned about the size of the crystals, which were larger than those seen in other brands. If your cat has sensitive paw pads, it may dislike the feel of this litter.


  • Outside pan is not tracked.
  • Excellent urine absorption


  • Not environmentally friendly
  • The crystal particles are quite big.


Best Tofu Litter – Natural Paw Tofu Cat Litter


  • Material for litter: dry tofu, corn
  • Scented: Yes
  • Clumping: Yes
  • Biodegradable: Yes

Yes, tofu-based kitty litter exists! Natural Paw Tofu Cat Litter is recommended over other kinds of tofu-based cat litter on the market.

This litter is sometimes the greatest option because it does not leave a trail of litter like some other sorts. Natural Paw Tofu Cat Litter is also environmentally friendly, as it is biodegradable, flushable, and compostable.

The litter is available in two scents: lavender and charcoal. Some people would have preferred an unscented option, however this brand does not provide that option.

If you have a large litter tray or numerous litter trays to fill, this brand can get costly.


  • Eco-friendly
  • Excellent urine absorption
  • There is no tracking.


  • There is no unscented option.
  • Pricey

Choosing the Best Cat Litter for Picky Cats: A Buyer's Guide

Why Is Choosing the Correct Litter Important?

Cat litter is frequently overlooked because it is something that is used for a brief period of time and then discarded.

Creating a clean and appealing location for your cat to relieve themselves, on the other hand, is critical for both their comfort and yours.

If a cat is dissatisfied with or discouraged by the litter for whatever reason, it will seek out alternative sites to urinate or defecate.

This will be less of an issue if your cat has access to the outside via a pet door. If your cat is an indoor cat, they may relieve themselves on your carpet or your clothes.

One of the biggest reasons cats end up in shelters is because their prior owners believe they can’t be housebroken.

Choosing the right litter for your cat is critical for both your cat’s comfort and your own peace of mind.

It may be necessary to purchase a few different litters before determining which one your fussy cat loves. But once you’ve found the appropriate litter, your cat will be grateful!

Advice on Choosing Cat Litter

Consider using unscented litter. Strong or unexpected odors may be the primary reason your cat avoids using the litter.

Even though the smell is pleasing to you, it may be too much for the cat. Some perfumed litters are intended to hide odors. Look for natural herbal scented litter if you wish to try scented litter.

Consider the texture. There are numerous litter textures available on the market. Do you have any doubts regarding which one would be more comfy for your cat?

Consider your own feet. Is walking barefoot on fine sand or gravel more comfortable? Coarser litter may not be the ideal choice if your cat has sensitive pads. However, choosing a finer texture may result in more dust.

Think about your litter box. Your cat may be able to follow the litter around your house more readily if you use finer-textured litter.

Consider putting the litter in a pan with rough edges or steps to assist in brushing off extra litter. Alternatively, place a textured mat beneath the litter pan.

The environmental impact There are many biodegradable and compostable litters on the market that are affordable.

Because the litter must be disposed of after use, having litter that decomposes or can be flushed is an environmentally responsible option.


Choosing the best cat litter for your fussy cat might be difficult. BestForPets (bestforpets.org) wishes our cats could talk and tell us which litter they prefer at this time of year.

Until cats can communicate, it is recommended that you purchase two of the best kinds of cat litter for picky cats to determine which one your cat prefers.

If you want to try a lighted scented litter, Dr. Elsey’s Precious Cat Attract Clumping Clay Cat Litter is a fantastic option.

sWheat Scoop Natural Unscented Clumping Wheat Cat Litter is another fantastic option if you want to try an unscented eco-friendly litter. Enjoy your litter shopping!

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles