BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 9 Best Dog Training Shock Collars

A contentious kind of training collar, shock collars are sometimes known as e-collars. They are used to correct the behavior of a dog.

Common uses are of barking prevention, field recall, and other behavior modification and training techniques.

The majority of shock collars have a moderate setting that emits a beep or vibrates against the dog's neck, but they may also emit a brief static jolt. To prevent harm, you must pick a high-quality model that functions as intended.

Additionally, it is essential that you utilize the collar correctly and as part of a comprehensive training program; otherwise, it may do more behavioral damage than benefit. There are several models, including those with diverse configurations.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) has made a list of reviews of the best dog training shock collars on the market right now to help you find the best one for your dog and your training method.


PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Collar- Best Overall

The PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Collar is affordable, has a range of about 1,000 feet, and is adjustable to suit any dog weighing up to 140 pounds.

It has four types of training: vibration, sound, continuous shock, and convulsive shock. And it has eight vibration and shock levels.

The collar is composed of a strong but comfortable material and is brightly colored, making it easier to locate if your dog escapes. It is also waterproof, so it may be given to Spaniels and other dogs that like a refreshing swim.

The longer-than-average range permits off-leash training, particularly recall, while the beep setting serves as an alternative to clicker training and may be extremely successful as a form of positive reinforcement.

The controls are straightforward, allowing for rapid correction level adjustments and usage of any setting. It has been created for blind usage and is useful for both rookie and expert trainers.


  • 1,000 ft range
  • Four practice modes
  • 8 setting levels
  • Vividly colored
  • Waterproof


  • Not for dogs under 10 pounds
  • Only suitable for two dogs

PetSafe Big Dog Training Collar- Best Value

The PetSafe Big Dog Training Collar is inexpensive, very user-friendly, and in addition to a static shock setting, it can also emit an audio beep to attract your dog’s attention.

It can only be used to educate one dog at a time, its range is 300 feet less, and it offers fewer possibilities than our top selection.

However, the range should be sufficient in the vast majority of cases, the beep and static shock combo will be sufficient for most dogs and training programs, and the PetSafe Big Dog Training Collar’s pricing makes it one of the finest dog training (shock) collars for the money.

It is only suited for dogs older than 6 months and weighing more over 40 pounds; if your dog is smaller than this, you will need to find an alternative.


  • QuickFit buckle is simple to use.
  • Low battery indicator lights
  • Automatic shutdown protects from overstimulation.
  • Cheap


  • Only appropriate for dogs above 40 pounds
  • Only applicable with 1 dog

Premium Remote Dog Training Collar by Educator By E-Collar

The Educator By E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar is a costly training collar, but it has 100 stimulus levels plus 60 boost levels, 3 kinds of training alerts, a range of 1,750 yards, and a battery life of up to 72 hours.

The receiver and remote are waterproof, and the gadget is suited for any dog over 6 months of age and above 5 pounds in weight.

The collar is equipped with two sets of contact points, allowing you to fit the collar to your dog regardless of their size or hair length.  Short-pointed collars do not often function well with long-haired dogs.

The collar includes other capabilities, such as a nightlight that makes it easier to locate your dog in low light, and it just takes two hours to completely recharge, making it very handy.

The only true issue with this equipment, other than the exorbitant price, is that it is only extendable for up to two dogs.


  • Lots of varied settings
  • Waterproof
  • Invoicing in 2 hours
  • 1,750-yard range


  • Expensive
  • Expandable just for two dogs

PetSpy P620 Dog Training Collar, Waterproof

The PetSpy P620 Waterproof Dog Training Collar is a lightweight collar with shock, noise, and vibration modes. It has a range of 650 yards, and the transmitter and receiver are both waterproof.

Using rubber bands, the collar is not the most comfortable, and the points are ineffective on dogs with really long and thick hair.

The system can only be extended to accommodate two dogs. Despite having 16 adjustment settings, this collar is much more costly than the top two models on our list.

Despite the higher price, it does not provide any more features or a finer degree of customization.


  • Extent of 650 yards
  • Can simultaneously charge transmitter and receiver


  • Expensive
  • Quite simple for the price.

DogCare Shock Collar for Dog Training

The DogCare Shock Dog Training Collar is affordable, provides extensive control over the intensity of punishment administered to your dog, and has control over up to 9 channels, allowing it to be used to teach up to nine dogs simultaneously.

Most other transmitters only support a maximum of two channels. The remote has three distinct training modes: beep, vibration, and shock.

It includes an adjustable shock rating from 0 and 99, allowing you to tailor it to the size of your dog. It fits dogs weighing up to 100 pounds and is ideal for dogs weighing above 15 pounds.

The DogCare Shock Dog Training Collar is equipped with a locked keypad to avoid inadvertent shocking, but its 330-yard range is quite restricted.


  • Manage up to nine pets with one remote
  • 3 modes and 99 settings
  • Lock with security keypad


  • Not appropriate for tiny breeds
  • 330-yard signal range may be increased
  • Not easily adaptable

SportDOG YardTrainer Dog Collar for Training

The SportDOG YardTrainer Training Dog Collar is more costly than the majority of the products on our list. Despite its price, it only has a 300-yard range, two modes (static shock and noise), and eight stimulation intensities.

All of these specs are beaten by other, cheaper versions. The SportDOG Yard Trainer Training Doc Collar may, however, be used on dogs weighing 8 pounds, which is much lighter than the majority of versions.

Additionally, it is waterproof, so it may be used in any weather and in any circumstance. Also included are two sets of points, one of which is designed for dogs with longer coats.

The battery does take a long time to charge, and the system will only function with single dogs, so if you are looking for a single remote to operate with numerous dogs at once, you will need to search elsewhere.


  • Works for dogs weighing up to 8 pounds
  • Waterproof
  • Two sets of points; applicable to all coat lengths


  • Taking a very lengthy time to charge.
  • Just two modes
  • Minimal stimulation settings
  • Not suitable for several dogs

Remote Petrainer 998DRB Dog Training Collar

The Petrainer 998DRB Remote Dog Training Collar has vibration, static, and noise alert settings.

The modes include 100 degrees of intensity, the collar has a limited range of 330 yards, and it is designed for dogs weighing more over 10 pounds. The length may be changed between 14 and 24 inches.

The collar is water-resistant, and the remote’s LCD screen is illuminated to display mode, intensity, and battery level settings.

The prongs on this collar are too short for dogs with long hair and thick coats. Even though the maker says it can fit a 10-pound dog, it would be a very loose fit.

Additionally, there have been quality control difficulties, with some devices failing after a few usage and others not functioning at all.

After a few months of ownership, the batteries lose their ability to keep a charge due to the rapid degeneration of the batteries.


  • Cheap
  • Can purchase a pair of collars.


  • The collar is too large for a 10 pound dog.
  • Quality concerns
  • 330-yard range
  • Batteries die fast

iPets PET619S Dog Training Collar, Waterproof

The iPets PET619S Waterproof Dog Training Collar is a shock collar with three customizable settings: shock, vibration, and beep.

It includes an intensity dial for fast and simple intensity adjustments, however it does not support changing settings for various modes.

The majority of owners would want to utilize the vibration mode at a greater intensity than the shock mode, however the dial is practically stuck between the two modes.

The controller is compatible with two collars, however the set is expensive, the controller lacks an LCD display, and the unit’s 330-yard range is much less than that of most of its rivals.

Even though the charger includes a splitter wire, the batteries lose their charge rapidly, which is particularly frustrating given that this is not the least expensive shock collar available.


  • The controller employs two distinct collars
  • The adjustment dial is simple to use.


  • No distinct changeable intensity level for various modes
  • No LCD display
  • Not even close
  • Batteries don’t last long
  • 330-yard range

Teacher With An E-Collar Waterproof Training Collar for Dogs

A costly shock training collar, the Educator By E-Collar Waterproof Dog Training Collar is waterproof.

It comes in a package with one or two collars that may be operated independently by remote, and the set can be expanded to accommodate up to four dogs.

It has vibration, noise, and static modes. It has a half-mile range, or 880 yards. There are 100 stimulation levels, as well as a boost level between 1 and 60 that provides additional stimulation.

The maximum stimulation setting avoids overstimulation by accident. The receiver weighs just 2.4 ounces and is suited for any dog weighing over 5 pounds.

Although this set contains some useful features, it is prohibitively pricey and unnecessarily complex. In addition, the collar’s nightlight is difficult to locate on dogs with medium to long hair, and the vibration levels cannot be adjusted.


  • Supports up to four dogs.
  • 880-yard range
  • Numerous settings


  • Too difficult
  • Too costly
  • It is difficult to view nightlight.
  • No vibration adjustment

Buyer's Guide: Choosing the Best Dog Training Shock Collar

The shock collar is a contentious training device since it is essential to administer some type of electrical stimulation to dogs in order to deter them from engaging in undesirable behavior. However, many of these gadgets feature other options, such as vibration and noise warnings, that may also be used in an efficient training plan.

When Should Shock Collars Be Used?

A shock collar utilizes negative rather than positive reinforcement. Effectively, it is used to discourage a dog from engaging in an unwanted behavior by punishing it when it does so.

They are controversial and should only be used after positive reinforcement training approaches have been exhausted and experienced trainers have been unable to assist.

Specifically, you should consider them in the following circumstances:

Whether your dog barks at the neighbors or suffers from leash anxiety and barks at other dogs, it may make walk time a nightmare for you and your dog, not to mention the target of your dog’s ire.

If your dog has a strong sense of wanderlust and attempts to escape at every chance, a shock collar may help limit them within the bounds of your garden or other area.

Canine safety – Hunters and trainers may use this form of training technique to deter a dog from approaching snakes or other dangerous creatures, as well as from engaging in any behavior that might result in damage, disease, or danger.

Hostility – Whether your dog is violent toward other dogs or, even worse, towards humans, a shock collar may be able to help manage this aggression. However, with this form of training, your dog may link strangers and other dogs with the unpleasant feeling of being shocked, which may have the reverse effect and increase their aggression.

Shock Collar Attributes

Consider the following things when buying for a shock collar to guarantee you acquire the proper one for you and your dog.

Range of Remote Shock Collar

Shock collars are remote-operated. By pushing a button on the remote, you may set the correction mode and strength and then administer the noise, vibration, or shock. Every collar and remote will have an effective range. If the distance between the controller and collar exceeds this range, the device will not function.

Using a training collar in the yard should not need a long range, but if you want to keep your dog from wandering off, you may find collars with a range of several hundred yards or even a mile.

Multichannel Controllers

At least one collar will be controlled by a controller. When you hit the button, it will activate any collar whose frequency matches the one chosen on the controller. If you have two or more dogs, you should avoid shocking them both while just one is misbehaving.

Multiple-channel controllers allow you to choose a collar and operate it independently. Some setups enable you to handle up to nine dogs, although the majority allow just two collars.

Shock Collar Modes

The metal contacts of a shock collar are in touch with your dog’s skin. When the button is pressed, a shock is administered to your dog. This is the setting for shock.

The majority of controllers provide additional modes, such as noise and vibration:

The noise option may be used in lieu of a clicker for positive training, enabling you to administer a beep or click when your dog accomplishes a desired activity.

To catch your dog’s attention without using an electric shock, vibration is employed. The vibration setting should be sufficient for your dog.

Variable Settings

Some dogs need a stronger jolt to gain their attention. This may be accomplished by increasing the variable settings available on the majority of collars. Some give 9 or 10 variable settings, while others provide up to 100 variable settings with 50 or 60 boost settings for when your dog does not react to the standard levels.

A collar with 10 settings does not necessarily provide a weaker or stronger shock than one with 100 settings, but it does not provide the same degree of varied flexibility.

Keep in mind that adjusting a variable setting may only affect the shock collar, while the vibration may be fixed; thus, if you want to be able to adjust both modes, confirm that the model you choose has this feature. Some versions, especially those with movable dials as opposed to buttons, do not permit changing settings across modes, thus if you have it set at a moderate level 5 for vibration and shock modes, this is the setting.

LCD Panel

LCD panels are advantageous because they can show the current mode, the changeable setting level, and the battery level. However, displays use more battery power, therefore devices with LCD panels may need to be charged more often. Ensure that the LCD screen is illuminated if you want to use it at night; otherwise, you won’t be able to see it effectively.

Collars for Dog Training with Nightlights

If you want to walk your dog at night or in the dark, it may be difficult to locate them when the light fades. A nightlight may be useful. Some collars are equipped with a nightlight that illuminates either constantly or on demand, letting you to locate your furry companion more readily.

Waterproof Training Collars for Dogs

Some dogs hate water and refuse to walk in the rain, but others like splashing about in enormous puddles. If your dog likes the water rather than avoiding it, you should pick a collar that is waterproof. A waterproof controller is advantageous when it rains, since it prevents the controller from shorting regardless of the weather.


1. Will my dog be harmed by the electric stimulation of a shock collar?

A shock collar should never be adjusted so as to cause discomfort to your dog. Although the shock is intended to be an unpleasant distraction, it should not harm your pet. Use one of the lowest/least-intense settings when uncertain.

2. How snugly should the collar fit around the neck of my dog?

To provide constant stimulation, the receiver must fit snugly against your dog’s neck. Before attempting a higher level, consider adjusting the collar and ensuring that the contact points are in place if your dog is not reacting to the signal. If your dog seems uncomfortable or has difficulty breathing, relax the straps.

3. How do I determine which setting to employ?

We suggest seeing a trainer about proper use. Generally speaking, you should always begin with the lowest setting. At the optimal setting, your dog should react with an ear prick or a little head or neck movement. The level is too high if your dog yelps or displays any evidence of physical suffering.

4. After adjusting the collar, is it OK to trim excess straps?

While this is feasible with certain collars, the reception antennas of others may be concealed inside the strap. Before trying to shorten the collar, we suggest carefully reading the manufacturer’s instructions to prevent irreparable damage to the equipment.


If you want good outcomes, you must apply a shock collar appropriately and compassionately.

When used improperly, this sort of training collar may do more damage than good and may induce undesirable behavior in your dog. In addition to leaving a physical mark, a low-quality shock collar may cause harm to your dog’s neck.

Choose one with the number of channels according to the number of dogs you own, with the modes and changeable settings you desire, and with the required range.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) discovered that the PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Collar had the best mix of cost, modes, and customizable settings, along with a remarkable range.

The PetSafe Big Dog Training Collar is not only ideal for large-breed dogs, but it is also priced affordably while being simple to install and giving enough settings, although without multi-channel options.

The PetSafe Big Dog Training Collar is a moderately-priced collar that we suggest if you are seeking for one. Our evaluations should assist you in selecting the best dog training shock collars for your specific training needs.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles