LogoPet-1.png
BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 9 Best Dog Pads

No matter what you call them—potty pads, puppy pads, or pee pads—these absorbent blankets are an important part of housebreaking a puppy.

Effective housebreaking requires teaching your dog consistent routines. The proper puppy pad not only promotes good housebreaking skills but also makes cleanup as easy as tossing the pad and replacing it with a new one.

After testing twenty different puppy pads in a lab in New York, we found that the Bulldogology Premium Puppy Training Pads are the best option overall.

You'll never have to worry about puppy urine getting on your hands or floors again because the Bulldogology training pads can soak up smells and keep liquids in the right place.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) also tested a lot of other puppy training pads that got great reviews from our volunteer testers and worked very well.

Here are the best dog pads based on our findings.

Reviews

Bulldogology Premium Puppy Training Pads are the best overall

 

 

Scent: None | Dimensions: Regular, 24 x 24 in.; XL, 24 x 35 in. | Absorbency: Regular, 7-9 cups; XL, 7-9+ cups

Our testers enthusiastically endorse the Bulldogology Puppy Training Pads. They are extraordinarily absorbent and can contain numerous cups of liquid without leaking. When our testers utilized a combination of liquid and solid material, they did not rip or get weighted down.

The Bulldogology Premium Puppy Training Pads are comprised of many layers of material meant to absorb liquids and bring them towards the pad’s core, including an exterior layer of “attractive fabric” and a second layer that locks in odors.

The superabsorbent polymer (SAP) at the pad’s core absorbs and holds liquids most efficiently, transforming powder into a gel that does not discharge water onto the floor or hands.

The efficacy, durability, fragrance (and how well it absorbs odors), ease of cleanup, and overall value of each puppy pad were evaluated using several tests and five distinct parameters.

The Bulldogology Puppy Training Pads scored a perfect grade in every category but overall value, as they are more expensive than numerous other training pads that we suggest.

During testing, we put a mixture of water and vinegar onto the Bulldogology puppy mat until it reached its maximum absorbency.

The training pad’s edges stayed dry after being soaked, making it easy to pick up. Surprisingly, even touching the moist area of the urine pad felt almost dry.

When removing the soggy puppy pad off the ground, the Bulldogology pad did not feel as like it was ready to rip or come apart. After finishing, there was no leakage and the floor is dry.

The Bulldogology Puppy Training Pads are also available in an assortment of sizes, materials, and numbers. The normal pee pads are supplied in quantities of 50, 100, and 150. XL pads measuring 24 by 35 inches are also available in quantities of 40, 60, 180, and 360.

Additionally, Bulldogology makes it simple to subscribe, so a regular supply of pee pads will be sent to your house.

The activated carbon version of the Bulldogology Puppy Training Pads has an extra charcoal layer that is meant to absorb odors more thoroughly (though we find the standard pads very effective at scent absorption already).

The Bulldogology pee pads also include a pheromone attractant, which we were unable to test under laboratory circumstances.

We were unable to determine whether or not this function is effective or merely a gimmick, as it was designed to attract the puppy’s attention during housetraining.

Other subtle elements, like as the sticky tape at each corner, which kept the Bulldogology pads securely connected to our test floor, were more clearly beneficial.

Notably, while the Bulldogology Puppy Training Pads were our favorite overall, several of our other choices functioned as well or almost as well. If another option on this list is more convenient to purchase, don’t be afraid to try it.

Pros

  • Slightly larger than the majority of similar training pads
  • The dry margin around the pad makes it simple to pick up
  • Completely absorbs odor
  • Similarly, a charcoal variant is also available
  • Multiple sizes and quantities sold

Cons

  • Expensive

 

Pet Parents Pawtect Pads are the Most Cleanable Washable Pet Urine Pads

 

 

Aroma: None | Sizes: 18 x 24 in., 24 x 36 in., 34 x 36 in., 41 x 41 in., 17-in. round, 36-in. round, 48-in. round | Absorption: three cups (18 x 24 in.)

While we tried a number of non-disposable choices, only Pet Parents’ Pawtect Pads Washable Dog Pee Pads delivered comparable performance to our preferred disposable solutions.

The substance in the Pawtect pee pads, a “WickQuick unique fabric combination,” was remarkably absorbent. We discovered that it rapidly absorbed many cups of water, drawing the liquid toward the pad’s core.

The primary drawback of this design is that there is no gap around the absorbent portion of the pad, thus there is always a chance that it will be little wet wherever you hold it to pick it up.

After absorbing vinegar, our testers were pleasantly delighted to find that the Pawtect pads did not smell.

Although there is no assurance that its odor control would be as effective with dog urine, its scent-absorbing capabilities appeared comparable to our favorite disposable pee pads.

Multiple fabric layers that were triple-stitched around the pee pad’s border gave the Pet Parents pee pads an incredibly durable feel.

The bottom layer of the Pawtects pee pad has a waterproof backing with a gripping, rubbery texture that adhered to the floor better than the adhesive tape offered with some throwaway variants.

The Pawtect is so cushioned that your dog may use it as a resting mat, making it a handy crate liner in addition to a toilet pad.

One tester described the Pawtect as the most outstanding of the available fabric options: “It is both the most absorbent and the tiniest. I am rather amazed by this.”

The Pawtect Pad we evaluated was among the smallest pads we evaluated, measuring just 18 by 24 inches. Numerous different sizes are available, including a 41 x 41-inch pad and circular variations up to 48 inches in diameter.

The Pawtects Pads Washable Dog Pee Pad is offered in pairs, allowing you to have one in use and one in the wash at all times. Naturally, the pads are machine-washable.

Pros

  • Machine washable
  • Unexpectedly absorbing
  • Various sizes, including circular pads
  • Strong and dependable structure

Cons

  • A fabric can become completely saturated

 

Glad for Pets Activated Carbon Training Pads are the most economical

 

 

Dimensions: Regular, 23 x 23 in. ; Giant, 30 x 36 in. ; Jumbo, 28 x 30 in. | Scent: None | Absorbency: Regular, 3 cups

Although not the cheapest pads we examined, there is no better budget option than the Glad for Pets Activated Carbon Training Pads, which are not only inexpensive but also among the most effective pads we evaluated.

We evaluated the effectiveness of the Glad for Pets training mat using three cups of vinegar and water. The paper margins also remained dry, making it easy to replace a pad without having dog urine on your hands.

The Glad for Pets pee pads took a bit longer to absorb liquid than our top selections, but this was a minor drawback.

In addition, the top layer was thin enough that when pushed with a finger, part of the sticky goo seeped through (of course, no one other than a product tester is likely to press their finger into the center of the wet puppy pad).

Additionally, the Glad for Pets training pads included activated carbon for enhanced odor absorption. While we did not observe a significant improvement in overall absorbency compared to non-charcoal pads, none of our testers detected any vinegar odor.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Available in adjustable quantities: 14, 30, 50, 100
  • Excellent scent absorption

Cons

  • Large sizes are unusual dimensions
  • A little slower to completely absorb liquids

 

Four Paws Wee-Wee Pee Pads are the best for large dogs

 

 

Scent: odorless | Dimensions: 27.5 x 44 in. | Absorption: five cups

The Four Paws Wee-Wee Gigantic Pads are 27.5 x 44 inches and offer far greater surface area than nearly any other disposable training pad (our best scented pick from Frisco offers a “Giant” size in the same dimensions).

During our tests, we discovered that it performed exactly as well as our other top picks, with its quilted lining guaranteeing that the floor underneath the pad remains dry after many cups of drink have been spilt.

The Wee-Wee Gigantic Pads include a big paper border so you won’t get your fingers wet, and the greater surface area allowed the Wee-Wee to absorb 5 cups of liquid without ever becoming soggy.

Price is the primary drawback of the Wee-Wee Gigantic Pads. There was no choice for bulk packing, which lowers the per-pad cost of many of our other preferred brands, among the pads sold by online vendors.

Pros

  • Utilizably huge size
  • Highly effective and absorbing
  • Large paper margin

Cons

  • Slightly plastic odor
  • Expensive

 

The Best of the Rest: IMMCute Dog Urine Pads

 

 

Absorbency: 8 cups | Scent: Unscented | Dimensions: 22 by 23 inches, 28 by 34 inches, 30 by 36 inches

Even though the IMMCute Dog Pee Pads were not our favorite in any single area, they were still among the highest-rated training pads we evaluated. Check out these training pads if none of the other suggestions on this list meet your exact requirements.

They were a superior option to the Amazon Basics Dog & Puppy Pads, which we also evaluated.

While the Amazon Basics scored towards the top of our test and are totally useable pee pads, we found them to be significantly less absorbent than our top selections, to the point where it was difficult to pick them up without getting our hands a bit wet.

The IMMCute pads are comparable in appearance and price, but they performed better in our testing.

After allowing fluids to soak through the pads, the subfloor was still entirely dry. In addition, there was no runoff when we raised the pads, and the paper margins remained dry, so our fingers were never wet.

Three distinct sizes are offered in packs of 14, 50, and 100 IMMCute pee pads.

Pros

  • Highly regarded performance at a low cost
  • Multiple possibilities for size and packaging

Cons

  • Exclusively available on Amazon

 

Bark Charcoal Training Pads is the Best Charcoal

 

 

Scent: None | Dimensions: Regular, 22 x 22 in.; large, 30 x 26 in. | Absorbency: Regular, 5 cups; big, 7 cups; XL, 8.5 cups

Even if the Bulldogology pads offer a few small advantages, such as being 2 inches larger, most puppy owners would be satisfied with the Bark training pads.

In our tests, the Bark Charcoal Training Pads worked just as well as our top-ranked product overall from Bulldogology. In addition, they are far cheaper, costing around $0.25 per pad as opposed to $0.58.

The primary challenge, though, is obtaining them. Bark’s training pads are offered in standard and charcoal variations, each in three sizes. However, as of the time of posting, only one of the six alternatives is available in their BarkShop.

In addition, orders require 5-10 days for delivery. Even while Bark’s pee pads are occasionally available on Amazon, they are generally sold directly by Bark, so don’t look for them in stores. Nonetheless, if you can readily obtain Bark’s pee pads, these are certainly your best alternative.

In our New York laboratories, the regular-sized Bark Charcoal Training Pads made quite an impression on our testers.

After the Bark puppy pads absorbed 5 cups of liquid with ease, one tester exclaimed, “This is insane.” “That is remarkable. This is perhaps the most successful one up to this point.”

For testing, we utilized a mixture of water and vinegar to see how efficiently the pads absorbed odors. Even while holding the pee pad close up our noses, we were unable to detect the vinegar odor.

When it’s time to dispose of the pad, cleanliness is just as crucial as absorbency. The Bark Charcoal Training Pads, like our other preferred dog pads, feature a border around the absorbent area.

It remained dry throughout, allowing you to pick up the pad without putting dog urine on your hands. Additionally, the subfloor was entirely dry.

While we evaluated a number of pads containing charcoal, sometimes known as “activated carbon,” we did not find that they performed better than typical absorbent gel pads.

The Bark pads are comprised of layers of charcoal and absorbent gel. Our top-rated selection from Bulldogology provides training pads with this dual-layer construction.

Even though the charcoal is intended to absorb odors more effectively, we did not find a significant difference between charcoal-containing and charcoal-free puppy pads in our vinegar test.

The adhesive tabs on Bark’s puppy pads make it simple to keep them in place on your floor. The pads also include a training instruction to assist you adapt your puppy to using indoor pee pads.

The Bark Charcoal Training Pads are offered in standard, large, and XL dimensions.

Pros

  • Excellent quality
  • Includes a training manual
  • Adhesive tabs for floor attachment
  • Extremely high absorption

Cons

  • Options are periodically unavailable
  • Restricted retail availability

What to Search for in Dog Pads

Absorbency

The majority of disposable puppy pads have a superabsorbent polymer powder sandwiched between many additional layers, including a pillowy top layer that absorbs liquid like a paper towel and a waterproof plastic bottom layer that prevents liquid from seeping through to the floor.

When in contact with water, the polymer powder absorbs and transforms the liquid into a gel, preventing the water from splashing or leaking elsewhere.

The powder in most puppy training pads may absorb between 3 and 5 cups of liquid. This is much more urine than the average dog produces in a day.

Dogs normally produce between 0.40 to 0.85 ounces per pound of body weight per day, however different veterinary sources offer somewhat varied estimates. 1 This means that a 10-pound dog may urinate no more than a cup each day.

Odor Control

While we discovered that our recommended puppy pee pads performed an adequate job of absorbing the scent of vinegar, it’s likely that your dog or puppy-in-training is capable of emitting odors that are considerably more potent.

Check investigating pee pads that include charcoal, which is good at absorbing odors (often sold as “activated carbon” or “activated charcoal”).

Washable versus disposable

Most disposable puppy pads are intended to be used for one day or few hours and then discarded. Washable puppy pads are meant to be placed in the washing machine after they become dirty.

While pee pads made with SAP powder are reliably absorbent, non-disposable alternatives employ a variety of processes, some of which are more successful than others.

While we found that our favorite washable pad’s quilt-like, dense fabric was effective at absorbing liquids, we were less thrilled with the other reusable pads we examined. A tray with a rectangle of artificial grass is a typical design.

We observed that they were essentially ineffective in eliminating odors and absorbing urine. Instead, liquid pooled at the bottom, producing a mess whenever the container was picked up.

How We Assessed Dog Pads

We acquired and evaluated twenty puppy pads in our New York laboratory to determine the best. The pads were placed next to one another on a linoleum floor.

Using a technique devised in advance, our volunteer testers submitted each pad to many tests, rating it on a scale of 1 to 5 and making measurements and observations as they went.

Each puppy pee pad was evaluated based on five distinct rating factors.

Our examiners began by assessing the efficacy of premium training pads. Using measuring glasses, we dispensed three to six cups of water over each pad.

Each brand was assessed based on its advertised capacity: if a pee pad said it could absorb three cups of dog urine, we graded it based on its capability to absorb three cups.

The water used on each puppy pad contains food coloring for visibility and vinegar so that our testers could also evaluate the aroma, measuring the capacity of scented pads to mask the vinegar smell and evaluating the smell-absorbency of unscented pads.

To test the endurance of the pads, we replicated solid dog excrement and saturated them with water to check if they tore or leaked when raised off the ground.

Finally, our testers scored each pad based on how effectively it kept the linoleum underneath dry and how simple it was to dispose of each puppy pad without coming into touch with filthy sections of the pad.

Testers searched for flaws, such as liquid pouring off the pad, moist flooring beneath, and pads that were drenched to the edges, causing the user’s fingers to become wet while picking them up.

After completing their evaluations, testers were informed of the price of each puppy pad they evaluated and then asked to rate the product’s overall value.

Conclusion

The Bulldogology Premium Puppy Training Pad is our top pick because it is a good size, it absorbs well, and you can get a charcoal version of it if you want.

Check out Pet Parent Pawtect Dog Pads if you’re seeking a non-disposable solution. Washable dog pads are made from a robust fabric blend that quickly absorbs liquids and can be cleaned in the washing machine.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) would like to thank visitors for visiting our site to learn about and research the best dog pads. We hope that you have selected the proper dog bed.

FAQs

How many puppy pads should I lay down simultaneously?

Typically, you only need to place one puppy pad at a time. The bottoms of high-quality puppy pads are waterproof and absorbent enough for two to three usage before disposal.

If you have a really large puppy or if your dog consistently misses the pad, you may want to try overlapping the edges of many pads to provide a wider surface area for your dog.

How long should puppy pads be used?

Generally, puppy pads are used temporarily while puppies are still young. If you want your puppy to eventually eliminate outside rather than on a puppy pad inside the house, you should move away from puppy pads as quickly as possible.

Some individuals, however, use puppy pads permanently and often in conjunction with a litter box or puppy pad holder.

Long-term puppy pad use is perfect for extremely little puppies, pet owners living in areas with harsh temperatures or weather, or pet owners who live in high-rise apartments or have other difficulties taking their dog outdoors to eliminate.

Are puppy pads effective for cats?

Most cats prefer to defecate in a litter box with cat litter, but they can also utilize puppy pads. For cats who frequently “miss” the litter box, pee pads are an effective way to prevent urine from leaking onto the floor.

As an alternative to litter, puppy pads can be used in the litter box, on the ground, or in a pee pad holder. Cats that stop using their litter box and urinate on rugs, clothes, and towels may benefit from puppy pads.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Comment

0.0
Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles