BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 4 Best Collars For Puppies

Goldendoodle coats are high-maintenance and vary from dog to dog. It is critical to have the appropriate New puppy owners are sometimes overwhelmed by the task of gathering all of the necessary materials for their new pet.

A collar would be towards the top of the list of puppy-nalia in terms of significance. Although a collar may seem to be a straightforward purchase, getting the proper one for your dog is not. How do you choose the best collar for your new puppy when there are hundreds of options?

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) highlighted the best collars for puppies in the post below. There are evaluations for each, as well as all the statistics you need to make an educated selection.

We've also put up a buyer's guide with advice on how to choose the proper size and which aspects are most significant. brush types that will keep their coats clean and tangle-free.


Outdoor Ultra Reflective Nylon Dog Collar Frisco

The Frisco Outdoor Ultra Reflective Nylon Dog Collar is the greatest puppy collar for the money if you’re on a tight budget.

The strong nylon webbing is sewn with reflective material, as the name implies, making your dog simple to see in low light. It is also available in four vibrant colors: pink, red, blue, and gray.

Frisco collars accommodate neck sizes ranging from 8 to 14 inches or 1 to 30 pounds. The collar is 58 inches wide and has a lightweight but secure toggle clasp.

The buckle is also slightly bent for your pet’s comfort. However, unlike our initial solution, it lacks a blocker.

The adjustable collar allows you to find the perfect fit for your dog, and the D-ring and tag ring are also strong. This easy-to-clean alternative lacks moisture-wicking and heat-retaining capabilities, but it is a safe and durable solution at an affordable price.


  • D rings and a long-lasting substance
  • Reliable curved buckle
  • Stitching that is reflective
  • Adjustable
  • Simple to clean


  • There is no buckle blocker.
  • It does not retain heat or repel water.


LED Dog Collar by Mighty Paw

The Mighty Paw LED Dog Collar is an excellent option if you spend a lot of time outside in poor light. While it is more expensive than our other alternatives, the two strips of LED lights guarantee that your pet is seen even in the darkest places.

Available for young dogs with neck widths ranging from 13 to 17 inches, the 1-inch width is likely preferable for bigger breeds.

Because it is made of weather-resistant nylon, it is impervious to rain and snow. It also has a charging seal made of rubber. Mighty Paw LED is an adjustable collar available in orange and green.

There are three settings for the LED lights: fast flash, slow flash, and steady light. When completely charged, the battery is reported to last six hours.

The extra rings for ID tags are missing from this collar. While the D-ring for your leash is reliable, there isn’t much additional space for identification.

Instead, you receive a USB charging cord as a trade-off. This collar is more costly than others since it is more comfortable, robust, and has a secure plastic toggle.


  • LED strips with three different modes
  • Weather-resistant
  • Material and buckle durability
  • Charger cover made of rubber


  • Larger breeds should use this.
  • There are no further tag rings.


Waterproof Dog Collar PawFurEver

If you and your dog like being outside and often return home in need of a wash, the PawFurEver Waterproof Dog Collar is for you.

Pet owners choose this alternative since it is simple to clean, does not retain scents, and is waterproof. It is suitable for neck sizes ranging from 7 to 1012 inches (or 1 to 20 pounds) and has a width of 58 inches.

The Biothane, polyester webbing is both long-lasting and comfy for your dog. It may, however, irritate their fur. Furthermore, this is another collar that does not have any reflective material for travels outdoors in low light.

The hues, on the other hand, are vibrant. There are five duo-color options available, each with metal hardware.

We did note that some clients found the belt-buckle stiff and difficult to fasten. Keep that in mind for wriggly puppies; also, it is not as adaptable as a standard collar.

PawFurEver is produced in the United States. It has a tough D-ring with ample area for a leash and ID tag.


  • Waterproof
  • Simple to clean and odorless
  • Material that is long-lasting
  • Contrasting colors


  • Buckle is more difficult to fasten.
  • Fur may be pulled by the material.
  • There is no reflecting material.
  • Not as versatile


Signature Leather Dog Collar by OmniPet

Another leather alternative is the OmniPet Signature Leather Dog Collar. It is made in the United States of 100% real leather and comes in black, pink, red, and blue.

This collar features the traditional belt-like buckle fashioned of a robust nickel, so it won’t come undone. A huge D-ring is also provided for ID and a leash.

OmniPet is available in lengths ranging from 8 to 14 inches for smaller dogs and pups. While we couldn’t find a weight guideline, you may choose between a 12-inch and a 34-inch collar width. Keep in mind that this is on the larger side for tiny breeds.

This collar is simple to clean, and the colors last a long time. The belt’s length, on the other hand, is known to be less than what is indicated. Furthermore, the durability and stitching leave much to be desired. Stronger puppies may be able to release themselves.

Like most leather collars, it lacks light-reflecting stitching, which is useful if you walk your dog at night. Although a little stiff, you may alter the size so your dog is comfy.


  • 100% real leather
  • Simple to clean
  • Nickel fittings
  • Adjustable


  • The construction is not long-lasting.
  • There is no reflecting material.
  • The length is short.
  • Stiff


Finding the best collars for puppies is simple if you know what you’re searching for and what matters. The PetSafe, BestForPets‘ (bestforpets.org) first option, is an excellent example of having all the bells and whistles, from safety to design. If you’re prepared to spend the money, the Mighty Paw LED Dog Collar is the ultimate in outdoor safety.

Buyer's Guide

Take a look at the tips below to pick the ideal collar mate for your new pet. We discussed how to determine your dog’s collar size, as well as some extra recommendations on aspects that are critical for their safety and comfort.

How to Choose the Correct Collar Size

There are many aspects of your puppy’s collar to consider, but the most crucial is size. It may give you and your pet a lot of trouble if it doesn’t fit properly.

If the collar is too large, they may be able to slide out of it. A too-small option, on the other hand, is unpleasant and may cause chafing.

To prevent these scenarios, be as accurate as possible while calculating the proper collar fit. Fortunately, the steps to success are straightforward.


  • A fabric measuring tape
  • Ruler and string
  • A meal bowl
  • A pen and a piece of paper


  • You want your dog to remain completely motionless in order to acquire the best accurate measurement. A little persuasion with sweets may go a long way toward assisting with this.
  • Encircle the center of their neck with your fabric measuring tape (or thread). You should be somewhat lower than their head, but not at the base of their neck.
  • There should be no slack, but it should also not be too tight. If you can comfortably get two fingers beneath the string, you’re on the correct road.
  • Make a note of the measurement on a piece of paper. If you used string, measure the length using a ruler.

We suggest one inch for smaller dogs and two inches for bigger breeds. If the one you choose occurs to run small, the additional space will assure an excellent fit.

If you can’t decide between sizes, go with the larger one. Collars are adjustable, and your developing puppy will appreciate the additional room.

Having your puppy’s weight on hand might also assist you in determining the proper size. Most collars indicate a weight, however the neck size should be evaluated first.

Apply the two-finger rule once you have your pet’s new collar in hand. Adjust it so that it’s tight but yet allows you to easily pass two fingers between the collar and fur.

Most collars may be adjusted to fit both pups and mature dogs. Although a “puppy-specific” collar is available, the ideal one will most likely be an adult option in a small or extra small size.


Dog collars are constructed from a variety of materials. Your lifestyle, personal preferences, and the breed of your dog will usually decide which one is best for you.

Webbing made of nylon and polyester

Nylon and polyester webbing are quite comparable, and they are the most prevalent form of collar material, as well as the most affordable.

Because both are so popular, anticipate a large variety of designs, colors, and styles. You will also notice that the build and durability vary. When selecting this style of collar, keep this in mind.


Leather is another popular material, although it is often more costly. New collars may be stiff and need time to break in. It’s also more difficult to clean. The reason for their appeal, though, is that leather collars may outlast the rest.

What you want to avoid is fake or bonded leather. Bonded leather is made up of scratches of genuine leather that have been bonded together. They are less costly, but their longevity is inadequate, and they will most certainly disappoint you.

Leather is our least favorite material for a dog. Young dogs have a habit of chewing on their collars, which may damage the leather. Your dog will outgrow it as well. We advocate deferring your investment till your pet reaches maturity.

Neoprene with Biothane

If you spend a lot of time outside, swimming, or fighting the weather, biothane and neoprene are two solid possibilities. Both materials are weatherproof, watertight, and simple to clean. Both materials are available in a variety of colors and designs.

Biothane is a kind of coated polyester webbing, while Neoprene is the material used in dive suits. The former is non-toxic and often less expensive. However, the longevity and construction might vary depending on the brand and manufacture.


Another consideration is the hardware and longevity of the collar. The buckle, D-rings, and adjustable guides make up the hardware.

The last thing you want is for a buckle to come undone or a D-ring to break, allowing your dog to escape from their leash.

The buckle and connector rings are often made of plastic or metal (generally nickel-coated). Plastic, contrary to common opinion, may be just as durable as metal and is typically kinder on your pet’s skin.

The comments area is the greatest location to judge hardware reliability. Look for recurring complaints that point to a manufacturing or design fault.

You should also investigate the various buckle styles. Do you prefer a toggle or a belt buckle? Is the buckle bent to fit around your dog’s neck? Also, do you need additional D-rings for ID tags?

Material for Reflection

Reflective material or stitching is necessary to ensure that your pet is visible to vehicles, cyclists, and people in general when the light is poor. Metallic threads reflect light and make your pet stand out when stitched.

Even if you don’t walk your dog at night very frequently, it’s a good idea to have some kind of reflection in case they get lost. It keeps them protected and makes them more visible.

Additional Information

Here are a few more details to think about:

Simple to clean

You should think about how simple it is to clean and eliminate scents from your collar. This is particularly important if you spend a lot of time outside with your pet.

Rings and ID tags

Some collars have ID tags or extra rings on which you may attach your own. In case of an emergency, it’s critical to have your dog’s information securely fastened to their collar.


This is a matter of personal choice, but it is worth emphasizing. Although there are some attractive designs and styles available, make sure you first check all of the safety boxes.

Otherwise, don’t be scared to buy multiples. You can always have a photo-op collar in addition to their everyday collar.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles