BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 9 Best Cat Litters For Picky Cats

Did your cat scoff and stick their paw into the most recent litter? Or perhaps you purchased a fresh litter on sale and they are dissatisfied with what you are providing.

Whatever the case may be, you must use a litter that encourages your cat to their box rather than your carpet. So, if you have a picky cat, we hope this post makes your life a little simpler.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) picked up eight of the best cat litters for picky cats we could locate that your cat would enjoy. Look no farther than these kitty-approved litters.


Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter – Overall Winner

If you’re having difficulty training your cat to use litter, Dr. Elsey’s Cat Attract solution is fantastic. It’s our overall favorite because it caters to all felines—and we have to say, it works!

So the clay litter has a natural herbal attractant that entices your cats to use it. With a highly sophisticated strong odor control composition, the product is designed for multi-cat families.

This litter has the proper texture in our opinion, and it’s 99.9% dust-free and hard-clumping. If your cat gets litter trapped on its paws, don’t worry.

The size of the particles should prevent this from happening frequently. Your cats will appreciate it.


Clump & Seal by Arm & Hammer Platinum Cat Litter – The Best Buy

If you’re looking to save money but still want your cat to use the litter box, use Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter.

This product contains no dust and will keep your cat’s nasal passages free and clear.

We were astonished by how well this cat litter clumps—it makes instant connections around waste and uses micro grains to keep the rest of the litter clean.

Arm & Hammer also offers a 7-day freshness guarantee, making this litter excellent for households with many felines.

For maximum freshness, it employs natural odor-fighting agents such as baking soda. You’ll love the added strength—and the cost!


Picky Cat – Premium Choice – World’s Best Cat Litter

Sure, no one wants to spend a fortune on cat litter, but it’s occasionally necessary to up the ante in order to keep the rest of your house pee-free.

The World’s Best Cat Litter Picky Cat is designed to fulfill the demands of all felines, particularly your troublesome felines.

Rather than being clay-based, this litter is made of grain and natural attractants. What makes this kitty litter even better? It is completely septic safe and flushable.

So, when you’re ready to clean the box, just drop it down the John. This clumping formula is ideal for multi-cat households with kittens, adults, and elderly.

So, no matter what stage of life you’re in, they’ve got you covered. However, the corn may not be as effective in combating odors as other solutions.


Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented Clumping Cat Litter – Recommended for Kittens

If your cat is picky about textures or smells, the Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented clumping cat litter might be just what you’re looking for.

This litter is 99.9% dust-free and free of any colours or fragrances that may bother your cats.

The important ingredient in this recipe is activated charcoal, which removes odors for up to ten days and has excellent odor control.

We like how simple it is to scoop this kitty litter. There are no particles that have fallen off into the clean litter for a later period.

It is fitted with Fresh Steps “Clumplock” technology, which allows you to easily remove any waste.

So, if you require a base clay formula that does not interfere with the senses, we believe your cat will agree.


Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter by Nature’s Miracle

Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter is a new mix that appeals to even the most picky cats—and we think you’ll like it, too.

This bio-enzymatic solution will eliminate odors while also appealing to your picky kitty.

We were a little concerned about how it would combat odors because it was scent-free, but it did so with style.

This litter bag comes in a resealable plastic container with a side handle, so be sure to reseal it after each use to avoid spills or accidents.

We would like to emphasize that the company guarantees a successful purchase—or your money back.

So, if your cat rejects this litter, you can receive a refund and go on to other options.

Buyer's Manual

What Kinds of Cat Litter Are Known to Irritate Cats?

There could be a variety of reasons why your cat is rejecting their litter. Every kitty is unique, and while they can’t tell you what’s going on, you can pick up on a few signs.


Some cats get irritated when litter gets stuck to their paws. You might feel the same way because you’ve undoubtedly found these microscopic particles on your items and flooring.

Aromatic Fragrance

Some cats are extremely sensitive to perfumes and smells. Most of the time, if these smells are too strong for them, they will avoid their boxes completely.

Unwanted Texture

Even if the litter does not adhere to their paws, your cat may dislike the way the litter feels on their pads. If you observe a lot of flicking,

Problems with Coverage

Cats have an innate predisposition to hide their excrement. If they don’t think their litter is performing its job, they may try to find a more appealing area of the house.


Dust can obstruct your cat’s airway, resulting in sneezing and breathing difficulties. If your cat thinks it’s too dusty every time they cover their waste, they may refuse to use it.

Quality Cat Litter for Picky Cats

If you have a very picky kitty, here are some points to consider when hunting for litter.

Texture: Soft

Some cats prefer a litter with a softer texture that is easier to sift through. They want to be able to simply cover up their trash without having to scrape through hard particles.

There is no tracking

When litter gets attached to a cat’s paws, it can be very irritating. In certain situations, it might even lead to overgrooming of the paw pads.


If you are afraid that your cat is allergic to the perfumes in cat litter, consider a scentless option.

Maximum Protection

Some cat litters, particularly the majority of non-clumping varieties, can make it harder for your cat to cover. Litter box troubles may arise if they are unable to properly bury their messes.


Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter was our favorite of all the fantastic litters we tried. It is actually intended to entice felines when you have litter box problems.

Because it is a specific composition, it will undoubtedly appeal to the pickiest of all cats—regardless of the cause of the problem.

If you want to save money, use Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter. It provides excellent coverage and is ideal for multi-cat households.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) believes it is not only the most cost-efficient option, but also the most effective.

Whatever cat litter from the best cat litters for picky cats list piqued your interest, we hope it will be the answer to all of your litter box woes.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles