BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

14 Best Cat Foods That Have Never Been Recalled

Cats are finicky creatures, and picking their food can be more stressful than deciding what to eat! When you and your cat are familiar with and like a brand, it makes sense to keep with it for the long haul.

However, there are situations when switching to a new brand makes sense. A product recall is one of those occasions.

Cat food is recalled by the manufacturer or the FDA, and it can be a frightening experience to find you've been feeding your cat something that could be making them sick.

Switching brands makes perfect sense at this point, but the sheer amount of options might be bewildering. Fortunately, our reviews are here to assist.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) has compiled a list of %product_count% of the best cat foods that have never been recalled. Look around for one that will work for your pet.


Canned Cat Food Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe – Best Overall

The Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food takes the top spot as the finest overall cat food that has never been recalled.

Because this wet cat chow is specifically designed to mimic a whole-prey diet, it contains bones and organs in addition to meat.

Each can contains around 92% meat, New Zealand green mussels, and organs, so you know it’s packed with natural nourishment for your cat.

Ziwi Peak canned cat food is designed to suit the nutritional needs of all cat breeds and life stages, so if you have a multi-cat home, this is an ideal choice to keep them all healthy.


  • There are two case sizes available.
  • The first ingredient is mackerel.
  • It has 10% protein and 4% fat.
  • Other tastes are also available.


  • There are none that we can see.


Canned Cat Food Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack – Best Value

The Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food takes the top spot for the best cat food that has never been recalled for the money.

This assortment of four delectable flavors will keep your cat happy and healthy on a budget. Each can contains a small amount of milk to make the Fancy Feast appealing to even the pickiest eaters.

Of course, this formula contains all of the necessary nutrients, minerals, and vitamins to keep your cat looking great. This is an excellent option if your cat enjoys a variety of flavors and textures, as it has bits of meat in gravy and pâté.


  • 24 cans in a case
  • The first ingredient is beef or fish.
  • Depending on the flavor, 9-11% protein
  • There are numerous tastes to select from.


  • Milk may cause stomach distress in some cats.


Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Cat Food – Premium Selection

We offer the Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned Cat Chow as a quality cat food that has never been recalled. This mixture is intended to fulfill your cat’s desire for meat.

The initial two ingredients in this blend are skipjack and tuna, however there are many additional flavors available if your cat chooses!

Earthborn Holistic exclusively uses premium ingredients that have been deliberately chosen for their nutritional value.

Founded in 1926, the company offers four generations of experience in making the best food for your cat, using only the finest ingredients.


  • Other tastes are also available.
  • Grain-free
  • As the initial ingredient, there is fish.
  • Suitable for all phases of life


  • Expensive


Tender Favorites Meow Mix Cat Food Trays with Poultry and Beef

If your cat enjoys a variety of wet foods, this multi-pack of Meow Mix Tender Favorites Poultry & Beef Cat Food Trays will keep them pleased with three different varieties that are all high in genuine meat.

The Meow Mix Tender Favorites is an excellent choice if you have a multi-cat home and are seeking for wet food that can be served to cats of all life stages.

Individual quantities are contained in the easy-open cups, and you can just pour the food into your cat’s bowl without worrying about scraping the last bit out!


  • There are two case sizes available.
  • Excellent value for money
  • Protein content ranges from 10-11%.


  • Some flavors contain by-products of meat.
  • Grain content


Dry Cat Food Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free

Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Cat Food is a high-protein food that will feed your cat’s growth spurts and active lifestyle.

Because turkey and chicken meal are the initial components, this is high in animal protein and is complimented by a variety of healthful vegetables and fruits.

It’s an excellent alternative for cats with sensitive digestive systems because it contains no grain or gluten. However, be warned that it contains egg, which some cats may react to.

Earthborn Holistic recipes contain excellent products that have been extensively evaluated before usage, so you can be confident in their safety and nutritious quality. Furthermore, this brand has never been recalled!


  • Protein content is 40%.
  • There are two bag sizes available.
  • Premium components are used.


  • Expensive
  • It contains an egg and peas.


Grain-Free Chicken & Fish Dry Cat Food Annamaet

Annamaet foods have been manufactured since 1986, and there has never been a recall. The main source of protein in Annamaet Grain-Free Chicken & Fish Dry Cat Food is chicken and herring meal, which accounts for 44% of the total.

Algae is added as a source of omega-3 fatty acids and chelated minerals to support your cat’s immune system.

This is an excellent blend, however due to its high fat level, we would not recommend giving it to an overweight cat. However, if your cat is underweight, this is a good option!


  • There are two bag sizes available.
  • Suitable for all phases of life


  • Expensive
  • It contains egg.
  • Overweight cats should avoid this product.


Indoor Health Grain-Free Dry Cat Food by Holistic Select

This is the Holistic Select Indoor Heath Grain-Free Dry Cat Food for you if you’re seeking for dry cat food that’s specifically created to support the health of your indoor cat.

It has 30% less fat than conventional Holistic Health recipes, making it ideal for indoor cats who are prone to becoming overweight.

While it has less fat, it still contains a variety of high-quality nutrients such as turkey, chicken, and a blend of fruits, vegetables, vitamins, and minerals, all of which are designed to help your indoor cat be their best from the inside out.


  • There are three bag sizes available.
  • There are no byproducts.
  • Grain-free


  • Only suitable for indoor cats.
  • There may not be enough calories for energetic kitties.
  • Expensive


Feline Chicken Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food by Nature’s Logic

Nature’s Logic Feline Chicken Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is the ideal companion to the Nature’s Logic kibble that we highlighted as our top overall pick, however these cans provide 100% balanced nutrition on their own.

This is a suitable option if your cat has allergies or sensitivities to lentils, wheat, maize, soy, potato, peas, or rice.

The use of actual chicken products as the first four components is a solid indication that this wet food is designed with your cat’s needs as an obligate carnivore in mind.


  • All-natural ingredients
  • The first ingredient is chicken.


  • Expensive
  • Can size is small.
  • Does it include eggs?


Now Fresh Adult Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Adult Grain-Free Recipe is Now Available! Because of the high protein level of turkey, salmon, and duck, Dry Cat Food includes 31% protein. The presence of canola and coconut oils provides ample of omega-3 and -6 fatty acids to your cat.

The gluten- and grain-free formula is free of soy, wheat, gluten, and fillers. It also contains no meat by-products or rendered meat, so you can be confident that you’re providing your cat with the greatest nutrition possible.

It does, however, contain pre- and probiotics to aid digestion, as well as a variety of healthful fruits and vegetables.


  • There are three bag sizes available.


  • Cats are not permitted.
  • Expensive
  • It contains egg.


Dry Cat Food Meow Mix Tender Centers Salmon & White Meat

The Meow Mix Tender Centers Salmon & White Meat Dry Cat Food is available in two bag sizes and is excellent value from a well-known brand that has never been recalled.

With 31% protein, this kibble is designed to entice your picky cat to eat with its tempting flavor. Each kibble piece is crunchy on the exterior and soft on the inside, which your cat should like.

While this is an excellent value, it does contain a few components that are not found in other of the products higher up on our list.

Corn and animal byproducts, as well as artificial colorings and flavorings, are examples.


  • Made in America


  • The first ingredient is corn.
  • Contains by-products of meat
  • Colorants are present.
  • Flavorings are present.

Buyer's Manual

If your cat’s regular food gets recalled, it can be a frightening situation. If this has occurred to you, it’s fair that you’d want to try a different brand of cat food that hasn’t been recalled.

In this tutorial, we’ll go over exactly what a pet food recall comprises and why it matters.

Why is cat food being recalled?

Customers who complain to the FDA that their cat food has made their pet sick, smells rancid, or is otherwise faulty will be investigated and tested.

They may discover hazardous quantities of some substances or the presence of microorganisms that could make your cat ill. The FDA will issue a recall at this point.

These can be requested recalls or statutory recalls. Manufacturers are then required to ask buyers to return any items to them or their stockers and offer a full refund.

Manufacturers can also recall cat foods if they feel something is wrong with them. This can also signal a less serious issue, such as faulty packaging labeling.

In certain cases, manufacturers will recall a cat food before an FDA recall is made in order to limit the damage to their brand.

In any case, having a cat food recalled is something that no brand wants. It can harm their customer reputation and, of course, have major consequences for whether their brand is purchased in the future.

How can I find out whether my cat food brand has ever been recalled?

There are several approaches to this. Of course, by selecting one of the brands in this study, you may be certain that there has never been a recall!

You can also visit the FDA’s website and search their list of recalled pet foods. Each recall will be recorded along with the date, brand name, product description, cause for the recall, and firm name.

Sign up for our alerts to be notified of any future recalls and never miss another cat food recall again.


You’ve undoubtedly realized how important it is to find a reputable brand of cat food that has never been recalled now that you know a little bit more about how and why cat foods can be recalled.

As a reminder, BestForPets (bestforpets.org) chose the Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food as the best overall cat food with no recalls.

Ziwi Peak only uses the finest ingredients, such as real meat, bones, and organs, to make your obligate carnivore cat feel and look their best.

We propose the Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food as the best value option.

This cat food provides all of the vitamins, minerals, and nutrients that your cat requires to keep healthy, but it is also inexpensive!

We hope that our reviews of the best cat foods that have never been recalled have helped you determine which brand of cat chow is best for your special feline.

After all, they must rely on us to select the best type of food for their needs, and choosing one from a list of brands that have never been recalled is a good place to start!

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles