BestForPets is reader-supported. Your purchases via our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Our Affiliate Disclaimer

The 15 Best Cat Foods For Picky Cats In Canada

Having a fussy eater cat can be stressful. Your pet deserves the greatest nourishment possible, but this can be difficult when your cat seems to reject everything you put in their bowl.

These are the best cat foods for picky cats in Canada, according to our reviews.

BestForPets (bestforpets.org) can help you choose food that is complete in nutrients and has an alluring flavor for even the pickiest of felines.


Best Overall: Taste of the Wild Canyon River

  • Trout, ocean fish meal, sweet potatoes, and potatoes are the main ingredients.
  • 32% protein content
  • 16% fat content
  • 424 calories per cup

Taste of the Wild’s Canyon River recipe is our pick for the finest overall cat food for fussy cats in Canada.

The first two ingredients in this diet are fish, which are strong in nutritional value and extremely appetizing for fussy cats.

Taste of the Wild takes pleasure in offering natural food that appeals to a cat’s carnivorous nature and is similar to what they would consume in the wild.

It contains no artificial ingredients, so you can feel comfortable about feeding it to your cat. The only drawback to this cuisine is that it is somewhat pricey.


  • 100% natural ingredients
  • Meat is the first two ingredients.
  • There are no artificial ingredients.


  • Expensive


Best Value for Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers

  • Poultry broth, chicken, liver, and wheat gluten are the main ingredients.
  • 9% protein content
  • 2% fat content
  • 67 kilocalories per can

Picky cats frequently prefer wet food to dry food, but it can be difficult to buy just canned food on a budget. That’s why we think Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers is the best cat food for fussy cats in Canada.

Quality ingredients are covered in thick gravy in this delectable dish. It provides appropriate hydration because it is moist food. Fancy Feast, on the other hand, contains poultry broth instead of water to provide additional nourishment.

This food can be fed alone or as a topping to make dry food more appealing. The gravy, on the other hand, adds extra calories, so you’ll need to be careful that your cat doesn’t acquire more weight than necessary.


  • Wet meal at a reasonable price
  • To provide more nourishment, use broth instead of water.
  • Provides complete nutrients
  • The gravy enhances the flavor.


  • Gravy contains additional calories.


Premium Natural Balance Green Pea and Duck Formula

  • Green peas, duck, duck meal, and pea protein are the main ingredients.
  • 30% protein content
  • 12% fat content
  • 410 kilocalories per cup

Natural Balance Green Pea and Duck Formula is recommended if your cat has a sensitive stomach or dislikes regular cat feeds.

Because this recipe contains a unique protein, it is suitable for cats with allergies and dietary sensitivities. It’s also a limited-ingredient product, which means it’s free of additives and artificial substances.

These characteristics raise the price, but it is high in protein and nutrient dense, which should offset the price because your cat will consume less kibble at each meal.


  • It contains a new protein.
  • Appropriate for cats with dietary sensitivities or allergies.
  • Ingredients are all natural.
  • High protein content


  • More pricey than many other alternatives


Science Diet by Hill’s Healthy Food – Best for Kittens

  • Chicken broth, chicken, pork liver, carrots are the main ingredients.
  • 6.50% protein content
  • 2% fat content
  • 71 calories per can

If you have a finicky kitten, we recommend Hill’s Science Diet Kitten Healthy Cuisine. This food is high in vitamins and minerals to help your child grow and develop, plus it’s delicious to keep them interested.

This recipe has been designed to support urinary tract health, eyesight, and heart function. It’s free of artificial preservatives and flavors, and it’s the perfect combination of flavor and nutrition.

Hill’s Science Diet is much more expensive than most other kitten food products because it is a premium food. Hill’s kitten food is also not available in standard-sized cans.

Because the serving sizes are smaller, you may require more food cans than you anticipate. Some customers have also reported that the dish has a distinct odor.

If you are sensitive to scents, you might not enjoy this cuisine. However, the pungent odor is usually what attracts choosy cats.


  • Encourages healthy kitten development and growth
  • Promotes urinary tract, eyesight, and cardiovascular health.
  • There are no artificial ingredients.
  • Complete nutrition is provided.


  • Expensive
  • Cans are smaller than typical.
  • Smells strongly


Vet’s Choice Purina Pro Plan LiveClear Allergen Reducing Dry Cat Food

  • Salmon, rice, maize gluten meal, and chicken by-product meal are the main ingredients.
  • 36% protein content
  • 16% fat content
  • 561 kilocalories per cup

Purina ProPlan LiveClear is our veterinarian’s recommendation for fussy cats. This recipe is also designed to decrease cat allergens for persons who are allergic to cats.

This high-protein snack contains antioxidants and probiotics to support immunological and digestive health. Even the pickiest of cats will eat this kibble because of the fish flavor.

Even if you aren’t allergic to cats, this recipe will help you reduce the amount of cat hair you have lying about the house. This is a feature that any pet parent will appreciate!

The most common criticism about this item is that it does not come in a resealable bag, therefore it can grow stale if not stored in a separate container.


  • Reduces the volume of hair and dander
  • Delicious flavor
  • Immune and intestinal health are improved.


  • There is no resealable bag.


Adult Cat Food Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein

  • Deboned chicken, chicken meal, pea protein, and tapioca starch are the main ingredients.
  • 40% protein content
  • 18% fat content
  • 443 kilocalories per cup

Blue Buffalo Wilderness provides high-protein cat food to aid in the maintenance of lean muscle mass. This recipe contains omega-3 and -6 fatty acids, which promote skin and coat health.

It contains Blue Buffalo’s unique LifeSource pieces, which are rich with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants for the health of your cat’s immune system.

The components in this meal are based on a wild Lynx’s diet, so it’s packed of excellent meat and healthful carbohydrates.

You can feel comfortable about what your cat is eating because there are no artificial ingredients or by-products.

Picky cats, like any other meal, do not all agree on what they like and dislike. Some customers swear by this food, saying it’s the only food their cat would eat on a consistent basis.

Other cats continue to refuse to eat it.


  • Aids in immunological health
  • Promotes skin and coat health
  • The main ingredient is meat.


  • All cats dislike it.


Dry Cat Food Fancy Feast Savory Chicken and Turkey

  • Ground rice, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, and beef tallow are the main ingredients.
  • 34% protein content
  • 17% fat content
  • 469 kilocalories per cup

Fancy Feast Gourmet is a delicious kibble that is 100% nutritionally complete. While Fancy Feast is well known for its wet cat food, its dry cat food contains the same high-quality flavor.

This one is flavored with chicken and turkey. The kibble is shaped differently than most, making it a wonderful alternative for cats who are finicky about texture.

The outside is gravy-bashed, and the bits are particularly crunchy. The peel-and-seal bag ensures that your cat’s food is always fresh.

However, the ingredients in this dish are not of the highest quality. The fact that the first element is a carbohydrate is also problematic.

Carbohydrates are not inherently harmful to cats, however they are largely filler and do not satisfy the needs of a carnivore.

This cuisine, however, contains no risky or harmful substances. While food may not be of the highest quality, getting a fussy cat to eat is sometimes the best thing you can do.

This meal nevertheless delivers complete nourishment and is popular among fussy cats.


  • Flavorful
  • Kibble that has been basted for extra appeal
  • For freshness, use a resealable bag.


  • The first component is a carbohydrate.
  • Ingredients of lower grade than many other possibilities


Extra Gravy Purina Friskies

  • Water, liver, meat by-products, and beef are the main ingredients.
  • 9% protein content
  • 2.50% fat content
  • 127 kilocalories per can

Purina Friskies Extra Gravy is a full and balanced diet that has been drenched in gravy to appeal to fussy kitties.

While gravy isn’t the most healthy ingredient, the food makes up for it elsewhere, and it provides extra water for cats who don’t drink much.

This food has a high protein content for canned cat food and comes in easy-open cans, making mealtime a breeze.

The possibility to switch this cat food is one source of concern. When your cat becomes accustomed to having gravy on their food, they will find it difficult to eat anything else.

Many cat owners are opposed to giving gravy at every meal, especially since it is not a suitable option for overweight cats.

Furthermore, while gravy may entice your cat to eat, some fussy eaters will lick off the gravy and ignore the meat. This destroys whatever nutritional value that the meal may have.


  • Completely nutritious
  • Food is more attractive with gravy.
  • Extra hydration is provided.


  • Gravy gives additional calories.
  • Some cats slurp the gravy from their meals.


Flaked Skipjack Tuna & Salmon from Wellness Signature

  • Tuna, tuna broth, water, and mackerel are the main ingredients.
  • 10% protein content
  • 3.50% fat content
  • 70 kilocalories per can

For added flavor, Wellness Signature Selects contains flakes of genuine meat packed in broth. While this meal has a strong fish odor, it is great for fussy cats who base their food selection on smell.

This cuisine has high-quality components that give excellent nourishment. There are no byproducts in this recipe, and for those who desire it, it is also grain free.


  • Total nutrition
  • Contains genuine meat flakes
  • Broth for added flavor
  • There are no byproducts.


  • Strong fish odor


The Tiki Cat Grill

  • Tuna, tuna broth, sunflower seed oil, calcium lactate are the main ingredients.
  • 16% protein content
  • 2% fat content
  • 151 kilocalories per can

Tiki Cat Grill‘s major ingredient is animal protein. This is critical for satisfying your cat’s appetite for meat.

This wet food is suitable for all ages and stages of life, so if your cat enjoys it, you won’t have to switch later. Broth enhances the appeal by providing aroma and flavor.

However, like with other fish-based dishes, this can be a turn-off for certain owners.

For fussy cats, Tiki Cat is hit or miss. Some cats love it, while others despise it, so you may have to experiment with flavors.


  • Broth to add aroma and flavor
  • The first ingredient is meat.


  • Smells strongly
  • All cats dislike it.

Buyer's Guide: How to Choose the Best Cat Food

A finicky cat might be difficult to feed. It’s especially difficult when you’ve done everything to get them to eat. Cats are fussy for a variety of reasons.

Let’s take a look at what these are and some options for feeding your fussy cat.


Neophobia is an unjustified fear of new experiences. While the term was coined to describe human dread, it is equally applicable to cats.

Changes in food, surroundings, and other factors can be confusing and frightening for cats. If your cat is refusing a new meal, try gradually introducing it.

Texture or temperature

When it comes to eating, cats have various preferences. For example, if you serve canned food straight from the refrigerator, they may refuse to consume it until it has reached room temperature.

Other cats prefer dry food over wet food. Some people enjoy pâté-style wet meals but dislike stew textures. Cats may refuse to eat until they receive what they desire.

A scarcity of food

Cats sleep 12 to 16 hours per day on average, thus many indoor cats don’t consume much energy.

They only require a certain number of calories, and they aren’t always hungry. If your cat eats nothing at all, you should be concerned, but a couple little meals each day is fine.

Sensitivities and allergies

Cats will sometimes avoid food because it makes them nauseous. If a particular cat food makes your cat vomit or gives them diarrhea, it’s likely that it’s causing stomach distress.

Just like humans, if a food makes a cat sick, they are unlikely to eat it again.

Feeding a Picky Cat

Here are a few easy ways to get your fussy cat to eat:

  • Provide a variety of food flavors (wet or dry).
  • Tuna water can be added to their meal.
  • Before serving, reheat the food.
  • Pour in the low-sodium chicken broth.
  • Add a teaspoon of wet food to dry kibble.
  • Use food toppers to add taste and texture to your dishes.


Feeding a fussy cat might be a trial-and-error procedure, but not all cat meals are created equal. These reviews of the best cat foods for picky cats in Canada should get you started.

To summarize, Taste of the Wild Canyon River is the finest overall cat chow for fussy cats in Canada. This meat-based diet is appealing to your cat’s taste buds and provides high-quality nutrition.

For the money, Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers is the best cat chow for fussy cats in Canada.

This diet allows you to feed wet food without breaking the pocketbook while yet providing comprehensive nourishment.

If you suspect your cat is suffering from stomach pain, we recommend Natural Balance L.I.D. Green Pea and Duck Formula.

This food has a unique protein and few additives to avoid allergic or sensitive reactions. We offer Hill’s Science Diet Kitten Healthy Cuisine for fussy kitties.

It provides appropriate nourishment for growth and development while while retaining flavor to keep your child happy.

Purina Pro Plan LiveClear Allergen Reducing Dry Cat Food is BestForPets‘ (bestforpets.org) veterinarian’s recommendation.

Picky cats enjoy this food, which also has the extra benefit of reducing cat hair and dander in your home.

Author Image

Dr. Deborah Fletcher

Deborah R. Fletcher, DVM, is a skilled veterinarian with more than 15 years of experience dealing with companion and exotic animals. She has experience caring for a variety of animals, including household cats and dogs, reptiles, birds of prey, and even primates. Dr. Fletcher is a valuable part of the BestForPets team, where she contributes to their aim of providing pets and their owners with the finest possible treatment and services.

Veterinarian (DVM) Dr. Deborah Fletcher


Rated 0 out of 5
0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Very good0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Related articles